Who is each option for?

The choice changes depending on whether the bourbon format, a particular pack label or a guest's ingredient requirements take priority.

Hosts keeping the bourbon format

If you want cocoa sandwich biscuits on the table while comparing sugar figures, start with sugars per 100g rather than a general impression of the product. Tesco lists 19.5g per 100g for its Free From Bourbon Creams; compare that figure with the other bourbon packs you are considering.

Hosts checking gluten and milk labels

Tesco labels its Free From Bourbon Creams gluten free and milk free. If a guest needs either exclusion, check the ingredients and allergen information on the pack bought for the party before serving it.

Hosts seeking an explicit reduced-sugar biscuit

Waitrose lists McVitie's The Light One Digestives and Rich Tea as reduced sugar. They offer that stated product description if you are willing to serve a biscuit that is not a bourbon cream; both contain wheat.

What should you compare?

Decide whether the biscuit must be a bourbon cream, then compare sugar on the same basis. Check guest requirements and serving quantities as separate decisions.

Priority What to check Your needs
Sugars per 100g Compare the same per-100g measure, not sugars per biscuit when sizes differ. Tesco lists 19.5g for Free From Bourbon Creams and 25.2g for its standard Bourbon Creams; M&S lists 24.7g for Giant Bourbon Biscuits and 36.7g for Extra Cream Bourbon Creams. I want a bourbon-style biscuit, so I need to compare the packs on the same basis before deciding which to serve.
Product description Read the stated claim separately from the nutrition panel. Tesco calls its Free From product gluten free and milk free, not reduced sugar. Waitrose describes McVitie's The Light One Digestives and Rich Tea as reduced sugar; they list 8.9g and 12.8g sugars per 100g respectively. An explicit reduced-sugar description matters more to me than serving a bourbon cream, so I am prepared to choose another biscuit style.
Ingredients and allergens Check the purchased pack's ingredients, emphasised allergens and precautionary statements. The conventional bourbon products compared here contain wheat; other ingredients and cautions differ by product. Guests have different ingredient requirements, and I need to identify each biscuit clearly when I put it out.
Party quantity Check pack weight, stated servings and the number of guests. Tesco lists 150g for its Free From pack and 296g for its standard pack; Waitrose lists 400g for Essential Bourbon Creams. I am setting out biscuits for sharing, so the amount to buy matters as well as the sugar figure.

What is easy to overlook?

  • Reading “Free From” as “reduced sugar”

    Tesco Free From Bourbon Creams list 19.5g sugars per 100g, but Tesco does not describe the product as reduced sugar. Its gluten-free and milk-free labels answer different questions.

    Use the sugars-per-100g figure when comparing bourbon creams. If the reduced-sugar description itself is important, check for it on the biscuit you choose.

  • Putting unlabelled biscuits on a mixed-guest table

    The bourbon products compared here have different ingredient and allergen information. Once biscuits are removed from their packs, guests may not be able to tell which information belongs to which biscuit.

    Check the packs you buy, keep their ingredient information available and identify any separately provided option when serving.

  • Using pack size to judge sugar content

    A larger pack contains more biscuit, but its weight does not tell you how its sugars-per-100g figure compares. Per-biscuit values can also reflect different biscuit sizes.

    Use per 100g for the product comparison, then use pack weight and stated servings to work out how much to buy for the party.

Which brands provide useful reference points?

These product lines illustrate different choices; the figures and ingredient cautions apply to the named biscuits, not every product from each brand.

Tesco

Tesco lists both standard Bourbon Creams and Free From Bourbon Creams, making it possible to compare two bourbon-style packs from the same retailer.

  • The standard product lists 25.2g sugars per 100g; Free From lists 19.5g per 100g and is labelled gluten free and milk free.
  • Neither product is described by Tesco as reduced sugar. Check the pack's current ingredients and allergen information before serving.

Waitrose

Waitrose Essential Bourbon Creams are a conventional 400g pack for hosts planning a shared biscuit table.

  • Waitrose lists 27.8g sugars per 100g and approximately 30 biscuits per pack.
  • The product contains wheat and may contain sesame; it is not described as reduced sugar.

M&S

M&S lists Extra Cream Bourbon Creams and larger Giant Bourbon Biscuits as distinct products, so their figures should not be treated as interchangeable.

  • M&S lists 36.7g sugars per 100g for Extra Cream Bourbon Creams and 24.7g per 100g for Giant Bourbon Biscuits.
  • Extra Cream contains wheat, milk and soya. M&S states that Giant Bourbon Biscuits are not suitable for people with nut, peanut, soya or egg allergies.

McVitie's

McVitie's The Light One Digestives and Rich Tea are alternatives when an explicitly reduced-sugar biscuit matters more than the bourbon-cream format.

  • Waitrose describes both as reduced sugar and lists 8.9g sugars per 100g for Digestives and 12.8g per 100g for Rich Tea.
  • Neither is a cocoa sandwich bourbon cream. Both contain wheat; check each pack's full allergen information.

Joybuy biscuit options

These are non-bourbon sandwich-biscuit options for a christening table if keeping a traditional bourbon cream is less important than considering a pack with a sugar-related product description. “Zero Sugar” and “No Added Sugar” are different descriptions; check each pack's nutrition panel rather than treating the wording as a like-for-like comparison.

Oreo Zero Sugar Sandwich Cookies, 97g pack

Oreo Zero Sugar Sandwich Cookies, 97g

A sandwich-biscuit option if the party selection need not be a traditional bourbon cream. The 97g pack is named Zero Sugar; check its nutrition panel, wheat and soya information, and sweetener warning on the pack before serving.

View on Joybuy
Gullon Zero No Added Sugar Cookies and Cream, 210g pack

Gullon Zero No Added Sugar Cookies and Cream, 210g

A cookies-and-cream option for sharing when a bourbon cream is not essential. The 210g pack is named No Added Sugar, which does not state its total sugars per 100g; check the nutrition panel, allergen information and sweetener warning on the pack.

View on Joybuy

Questions about choosing party biscuits

Is Tesco Free From Bourbon Creams a reduced-sugar bourbon biscuit?

Tesco lists 19.5g sugars per 100g for Free From Bourbon Creams but does not describe them as reduced sugar. If you need a biscuit explicitly described that way, Waitrose lists McVitie's The Light One Digestives and Rich Tea as reduced sugar; neither is a bourbon cream.

What should I check before serving biscuits to guests with allergies?

Check the ingredients, emphasised allergens and precautionary statements on the actual packs you serve. The conventional bourbon products compared here contain wheat, while other ingredients and cautions vary. Tesco labels its Free From Bourbon Creams gluten free and milk free, but the purchased pack should guide what you tell guests.

Does school-food guidance restrict biscuits at a private christening party?

The Department for Education's school-food guidance concerns England's school-food setting; it does not establish a restriction for a privately hosted christening party. Do not apply a school-meal rule to private catering without checking whether that rule covers the event.

How do I compare sugar figures when biscuits are different sizes?

Use sugars per 100g to compare the products, then look at per-biscuit figures and pack size when planning how many to serve. Tesco lists 25.2g sugars per 100g and 3.5g per biscuit for its standard Bourbon Creams, compared with 19.5g per 100g and 2.7g per biscuit for its Free From Bourbon Creams.