Choose cloud storage when automatic access across household devices and family sharing matter most; choose an external drive when you want a local copy that does not depend on a storage subscription. A network-attached storage device (NAS) suits a household prepared to manage shared local storage. For irreplaceable photos and documents, keep a separate backup destination and check that you can restore files and regain account access.
If photos, videos and documents are spread across phones, tablets and computers, look for a way to back them up and reach them from the devices your household uses. Check how sharing works before choosing a family plan.
A growing photo or video archive may call for a local copy that is available offline and practical to move between compatible devices. An external drive still needs a separate backup destination for important files.
When files would be difficult to replace, plan for accidental deletion, a lost device and loss of account access. Keep copies in separate destinations and test how to restore them.
Choose it when: Household members need files and phone backups available across their devices.
Allow for: An ongoing subscription for added capacity and dependence on account access.
Choose it when: You want a portable local copy of a photo or video library without a storage subscription.
Allow for: Connecting the drive and keeping its copy current; the drive is not an off-site backup by itself.
Choose it when: Your household wants a shared home archive and is prepared to administer it.
Allow for: Disk setup, ongoing management and a separate off-site backup.
Choose it when: Important files need both convenient everyday access and an independent recovery route.
Allow for: Managing two destinations and checking that each copy can be restored.
| Concern | What to check | Who this matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Access and sharing | Check each device’s access and upload options, then whether a family plan uses a shared pool or individual allowances. | If our files live on several phones and computers, we need to reach and share them without passing a drive around. Around 33% of consumers put multi-device access and sharing first. |
| Recovery | Check the plan’s restore options and keep a separate copy; try restoring a photo and a document. | Losing a device or deleting a folder should not mean losing our family records. For around 27% of consumers, recovery is the primary concern. |
| Local capacity | Measure the current library, check drive connections and leave room for another backup copy. | Our growing video library needs space and a local copy we can use offline. Local capacity and control come first for around 20% of consumers. |
| Account control | Review sharing permissions and the chosen service’s terms; set up sign-in protection and recovery options. | Before storing sensitive documents, we want to know who can open them and how we would regain access. Around 20% of consumers prioritise privacy and account control. |
A single local device can fail or be affected by the same incident as the original files. Cloud recovery has limits too: Microsoft says permanently deleted OneDrive recycle-bin files cannot be restored.
Keep important files in an independent second destination and test opening and restoring files from each copy. Synology’s backup guidance calls for an off-site copy.
Google says Google One family members share an upgraded storage quota. Microsoft lists up to 1 TB per person for as many as six people on Microsoft 365 Family. Those arrangements call for different capacity planning.
Check how much space each person currently uses, particularly for video, before deciding whether a shared pool or individual allowances fit.
Apple says account recovery can take several days or longer when the usual password-reset options are unavailable. Losing access to a cloud account can interrupt access to files held there.
Set up the available recovery options while you can still sign in, and keep recovery information securely apart from your primary device.
Samsung says the maximum rated speeds of its T7 Shield 1 TB depend on compatible USB hardware, cable and UASP support. A speed figure alone does not establish the transfer rate your computer will achieve.
Check the ports and cables you will use, and decide whether the drive is mainly for occasional backups or frequent large-file transfers.
iCloud+ is a cloud-storage and device-backup option for households using iPhone, iPad and Mac. Apple also describes browser and Windows access.
Google One adds storage across Google Drive, Gmail and Google Photos for households already using those services.
OneDrive and Microsoft 365 combine cloud file access with Microsoft productivity applications across several device types.
Synology’s NAS range is relevant to households considering a shared local archive and a separate backup destination.
Samsung portable SSDs are a local-copy option for households moving photos and videos between compatible devices.
These external drives offer local file-copy options; the Synology NAS is for a shared home archive. Choose capacity and connections for your devices, and arrange a separate backup destination for important files.
No image available
Consider this for a large local photo or video library that you want to copy between compatible devices.
The listed variant has 4 TB capacity and a USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 connection. Check your devices’ ports before relying on that interface, and keep another copy of important files.
No image available
This is a local-copy option for household photos, videos and documents.
The listed variant has 2 TB capacity and a USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 connection. Check device compatibility and decide how you will keep its copy up to date.
No image available
Consider this when a portable local copy fits your current library.
The listed variant has 1 TB capacity and a USB 3.2 Gen 2 connection. Check compatibility with the devices you will use; a local drive alone does not provide an off-site copy.
No image available
Consider a NAS if your household wants a shared local archive and is prepared to manage its storage and backups.
This is a two-bay diskless unit. Check which disks you need, the resulting usable capacity and the restore process; arrange a separate off-site copy for important files.
No image available
This portable hard drive is a local-copy option for a sizeable household file library.
The listed variant has 5 TB capacity. If you also use Windows devices, check the required driver and compatibility before buying; plan how to update and independently back up the drive.
Cloud storage can hold a backup copy, but do not assume a synced file remains recoverable indefinitely. Microsoft describes time-limited OneDrive restore options and says permanently deleted recycle-bin files cannot be restored. Keep an independent copy of irreplaceable photos and test restoring it.
Not merely because they share a plan: Google says family members share storage capacity, while their files are not accessible to others without permission. Check sharing settings for individual files, and note that family members must live in the same country.
Set up the account’s available recovery options, protect sign-in and test restoring a file before making the cloud account your main access route. Keep recovery information apart from your primary device. Apple says account recovery may take several days or longer when the usual reset options are unavailable.
No. A home NAS can serve as a shared local archive, but it remains at home unless you back it up elsewhere. Synology recommends a 3-2-1 approach that includes an off-site copy; check that you can restore files from that separate destination.