Who is this choice for?

Families sharing an occasional treat

A larger standard pack makes sense when several people want biscuits after a casual gym visit. Tesco Groceries lists a 400 g pack, compared with its 300 g Crawfords listing and M&S’s 165 g Extra Cream pack. Pack size does not make the biscuits a recovery-focused snack.

Regular trainees who also want biscuits

If the snack is meant for after intense or prolonged exercise, consider what else you will eat with it. The UK Sports Institute advises a snack containing carbohydrate and protein; Tesco lists 0.7 g protein per custard cream and Tesco Groceries lists 0.6 g for a Crawfords biscuit.

Households checking allergens

Read the label on the exact pack before sharing. The Tesco and Crawfords product information lists wheat and milk and says the biscuits may contain sesame; the M&S product information lists wheat, milk and soya.

What should you check before buying?

Decide whether this is a biscuit treat for several people or a snack intended to include carbohydrate and protein after exercise. Then compare pack size, the nutrition label and allergens on the products you can buy.

Priority What to check Your needs
Sharing size Compare the labelled pack weights: Tesco’s standard pack is 400 g, Crawfords is 300 g and M&S Extra Cream is 165 g. Check availability before relying on a particular pack. Several of us want biscuits from one pack, so its size matters more to me than an extra-cream style.
Post-exercise snack The UK Sports Institute advises carbohydrate and protein after intense or prolonged exercise. Tesco lists 0.7 g protein per biscuit; Tesco Groceries lists 0.6 g for Crawfords. If I am choosing food with post-exercise recovery in mind, I want the snack to include both carbohydrate and protein, not just biscuits.
Serving and label Check whether figures are per biscuit or per 100 g before comparing them. Tesco lists 3.4 g sugars and 1.5 g saturates per biscuit; M&S lists 40.2 g sugars and 13.5 g saturates per 100 g. I want to decide how many biscuits to serve and compare the labels on the same measurement basis.
Allergens Read the exact pack’s ingredient and allergen statements. Tesco and Crawfords list wheat and milk and may contain sesame; M&S lists wheat, milk and soya. Before putting biscuits out for everyone, I need to know whether anyone must avoid an ingredient or a stated possible allergen.
Availability Check the live listing and your delivery or store options. Tesco Groceries marked its Crawfords 300 g listing out of stock, while Sainsbury’s marked its 200 g pack out of stock. When I need biscuits for a particular day, a pack size on a product page is useful only if I can obtain the pack.

What is easy to overlook?

  • Using the family pack as the whole post-gym snack

    For intense or prolonged exercise, the UK Sports Institute advises including carbohydrate and protein in the post-exercise snack. Tesco and Crawfords list 0.7 g and 0.6 g protein per biscuit respectively.

    If that combination is your aim, have biscuits alongside a protein-containing food or choose a snack that includes both nutrients.

  • Assuming extra cream means a larger sharing pack

    M&S Extra Cream Custard Creams come in a 165 g pack, compared with Tesco’s 400 g standard pack. M&S lists 40.2 g sugars and 13.5 g saturates per 100 g.

    Choose between the styles for the biscuits you want, but compare the pack weights separately and use the same label basis for nutrition figures.

  • Planning around a listing without checking stock

    Tesco Groceries marked its Crawfords 300 g listing out of stock, Sainsbury’s marked its 200 g pack out of stock, and the Joybuy McVitie's Tasties 300 g listing said the product was no longer available.

    Check the current product page and delivery or store options before choosing a specific brand for a shared snack.

  • Applying one school-food assumption across the UK

    The Department for Education’s school food standards practical guide applies to England. It does not establish an HFSS classification for these particular retail packs or a rule for every UK school context.

    If the biscuits are being considered for a school meal or catering order, check the applicable nation’s standards and the school’s menu and procurement requirements.

Which product lines are relevant?

These pack descriptions refer to the named product lines, not to every biscuit made by each brand. Check the current listing and the exact packet before choosing.

Tesco

Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits come in a 400 g standard pack, the largest pack among the compared standard and extra-cream products.

  • Tesco Groceries lists the pack as suitable for vegetarians.
  • The product information lists wheat and milk and says it may contain sesame.

Crawfords

Crawfords Custard Creams are a 300 g standard pack with a vanilla-flavour cream filling.

  • An alternative pack size for shoppers who prefer this named product.
  • Tesco Groceries marked its listing out of stock. The product information lists wheat and milk and says it may contain sesame.

M&S

M&S describes its 165 g Extra Cream Custard Creams as having more vanilla cream and real custard powder.

  • An extra-cream style in a smaller pack.
  • The M&S label lists 40.2 g sugars and 13.5 g saturates per 100 g; the product information lists wheat, milk and soya.

Sainsbury's

Sainsbury's lists a 200 g standard custard-cream pack.

  • Its label gives per-biscuit figures, including 0.7 g protein and 3.3 g sugars.
  • Sainsbury's marked this pack out of stock on its product page.

McVitie's

McVitie's Tasties Custard Creams appeared in a 300 g Joybuy listing.

  • The named listing identifies a 300 g custard-cream pack.
  • The Joybuy listing said the product was no longer available; it is not the same product as the Tesco, Crawfords or M&S packs described above.

Custard creams on Joybuy

This 125 g gluten-free custard-cream pack is a smaller option than the 300 g and 400 g standard packs discussed for family sharing. Check its packet if allergens or particular nutrition values affect your choice.

Schar Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g pack

Schar Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g

For a custard-cream treat after the gym when a smaller pack suits you, this is a 125 g gluten-free option. It is smaller than the compared family-sharing packs; read the exact pack’s allergen statement and nutrition panel before sharing.

View on Joybuy

Common questions

Are custard creams enough as a post-gym snack?

If the snack is intended for recovery after intense or prolonged exercise, consider something that includes both carbohydrate and protein rather than custard creams alone. The UK Sports Institute advises that combination; Tesco lists 0.7 g protein per custard cream and Tesco Groceries lists 0.6 g for Crawfords.

Which compared pack has the most biscuits for family sharing?

Compare pack weights rather than assuming a biscuit count: Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits are sold in a 400 g pack, Crawfords in a 300 g pack and M&S Extra Cream in a 165 g pack. Tesco’s is the largest by weight of these three; check the current listing before buying.

Which allergens should I check before sharing?

Check the exact packet before sharing. The Tesco and Crawfords product information lists wheat and milk and says the biscuits may contain sesame; the M&S product information lists wheat, milk and soya. Do not rely on a different product’s label, even when the biscuits have the same name.

How should I keep an opened family pack?

Keep the biscuits in a cool, dry place and reseal the pack or transfer them to an airtight container after opening to help preserve their crispness. Follow any storage instructions on the packet.

Do the same school-food rules apply to these biscuits across the UK?

Do not assume a single UK-wide rule or an HFSS classification for a named pack. The Department for Education’s school food standards practical guide applies to England and does not classify these particular products. For a school meal or catering purchase, check the standards applicable to that nation and the school’s own requirements.