Who is choosing?

Hosts buying for a group

You want enough familiar biscuits to share. Compare the stated pack weights and any biscuit counts rather than treating “family pack” as a fixed quantity.

Hosts serving different preferences

You are weighing up plain custard creams against a variation or a mixed selection. In a mixed pack, only part of the total weight is custard creams.

Hosts accommodating food restrictions

You need to check each guest’s requirements against the full pack label. Tesco and Asda list wheat and milk in their conventional custard creams; Schär offers a separately labelled gluten-free option.

What matters when choosing a pack?

Start with the quantity you expect to serve, then decide whether biscuit variety, separate portions or a guest’s ingredient requirements change the choice.

Priority What to check Your needs
Quantity Tesco and Asda list 400g plain packs; Tesco lists Crawford’s at 300g with about 26 biscuits. Asda suggests 34 servings for its pack, which is not a guest count. I want enough biscuits for the gathering without choosing a pack size from its name alone.
Biscuit selection M&S lists custard creams, malted milk and bourbon biscuits in its 530g triple pack. Its separate Extra Cream custard creams come in a 165g pack. If guests want a mixture, I can choose an assortment; if they want only custard creams, I need to check how much of an assortment is actually that biscuit.
Ingredients and allergens Tesco and Asda list wheat and milk in their plain packs. Schär labels its 125g custard creams gluten-free; check the complete current label, including precautionary information, for a particular guest. Someone joining us has a food restriction, so the biscuits I serve need to match their stated requirements.
Separate servings Schär lists five inner packs of two biscuits. Tesco and Asda instruct shoppers to store their conventional biscuits in an airtight container after opening. We may serve biscuits at different times, so I need to consider what will remain unopened and how to store the rest.

What should you watch for?

  • Counting a mixed pack as all custard creams

    M&S’s 530g triple pack also contains malted milk and bourbon biscuits, so its total weight does not describe the quantity of custard creams.

    Check the biscuit types in an assortment before comparing it with a plain custard-cream pack.

  • Relying on an online description for an allergy check

    Tesco and Asda list wheat and milk in their conventional custard creams. An online description cannot establish whether the pack in hand meets a particular guest’s requirements.

    Read the actual pack’s ingredients and precautionary allergen wording before serving it.

Pack and brand references

Tesco

Tesco lists a 400g conventional custard-cream pack for sharing.

  • The listing states the pack weight and gives storage directions.
  • Its listed ingredients include wheat and milk.

Asda

Asda lists a 400g conventional pack and suggests it provides 34 servings.

  • The serving estimate can help with portion planning, but does not mean the pack serves 34 guests.
  • Its listed ingredients include wheat and milk; Asda advises airtight storage after opening.

Crawford’s

Tesco lists Crawford’s custard creams in a 300g pack with about 26 biscuits.

  • The stated biscuit count offers another way to plan the amount to serve.
  • The checked Tesco listing was marked out of stock; check availability when shopping.

Sainsbury’s

Sainsbury’s lists its own-label custard creams in a 200g pack.

  • Its listing describes approximately 16 servings per pack.
  • The checked listing was marked out of stock; buying more than one smaller pack depends on availability.

M&S

M&S lists a 165g Extra Cream custard-cream pack and a 530g triple biscuit pack.

  • M&S describes the Extra Cream biscuits as having more vanilla cream.
  • The triple pack also contains malted milk and bourbon biscuits; 530g is not the custard-cream quantity.

Schär

Schär’s 125g custard creams are labelled gluten-free and contain five inner packs of two biscuits.

  • The inner packs offer separate portions for a guest who needs this labelled option.
  • Check the full pack label against that guest’s requirements; the 125g pack is a different quantity from a larger shared pack.

Joybuy product options

This option is for including separately portioned, gluten-free custard creams alongside biscuits chosen for the wider gathering.

Schär Gluten-Free Custard Creams 125g pack

Schär Gluten-Free Custard Creams 125g

For a guest who needs gluten-free biscuits, this 125g pack contains five inner packs of two. Check the full label against their requirements before serving; it is not the same quantity as a larger shared pack.

View on Joybuy

Common questions

How many custard-cream packs should I get for Bonfire Night?

Estimate how many biscuits you expect to serve, then check the count on the pack where one is stated. Tesco lists about 26 biscuits in Crawford’s 300g pack, while Asda suggests 34 servings for its 400g pack. Those are different measures, and neither establishes how many biscuits each guest will take.

Can I serve ordinary custard creams to someone avoiding gluten or milk?

Do not assume they are suitable: Tesco and Asda list wheat and milk in their conventional packs. Schär’s 125g custard creams are labelled gluten-free, but check the complete current pack label against the guest’s particular requirements before serving.

How should I keep custard creams after opening the pack?

Follow the directions on the pack you buy. Tesco and Asda instruct shoppers to store their conventional custard creams in an airtight container after opening; Schär’s five inner packs of two offer a way to keep separate portions unopened until needed.