Who is choosing?

Bakers choosing chocolate for a cake

If the recipe calls for chocolate in the sponge or frosting, distinguish that ingredient from chocolates placed on the finished cake. Lindt’s cake recipe gives its dark chocolate and truffles these separate roles.

Bakers planning a custard-cream theme

Custard creams bring a vanilla-filled sandwich biscuit to the cake plan, rather than replacing the chocolate specified in a chocolate-cake recipe. Tesco and Crawford’s describe their custard creams as vanilla-filled sandwich biscuits.

Bakers serving guests with dietary restrictions

Check each biscuit, chocolate and other cake ingredient separately. Tesco’s standard custard creams list wheat and milk ingredients; Sainsbury’s labels its distinct Free From Custard Creams product milk and gluten free.

What matters when choosing?

Decide whether you need an ingredient for the bake, a finished-cake decoration or a biscuit element before comparing packs.

PriorityWhat to checkYour needs
Chocolate for the bake Check the recipe’s chocolate type and cocoa percentage, and whether it calls for chocolate in the cake, frosting or both. Lindt’s chocolate cake recipe specifies 70% dark chocolate for its cake and frosting. I need chocolate to incorporate into the cake or frosting, not a box of filled chocolates chosen for decoration.
Finished-cake decoration Check the form of the chocolates, the current ingredient label and how the recipe uses them. Lindt’s recipe places unwrapped LINDOR truffles on the finished cake. A box of individual chocolates suits my plan if they are for the finished cake or to accompany it as a gift.
Custard-cream biscuit element Check that the pack contains the vanilla-filled sandwich biscuits you want. If a milk- or gluten-free biscuit is needed, check that the specific product carries the relevant label. I want a separate custard-cream biscuit element rather than another kind of chocolate.
Ingredients and storage Read the current allergen information for every cake component and follow each pack’s storage instructions. The Joybuy listing for LINDOR Milk Chocolate Truffles says to keep them dry and away from heat. When sharing the cake, I need to check the decorations as carefully as the ingredients used in the bake.

What should you avoid?

  • Treating biscuits, truffles and baking chocolate as substitutes

    They can serve different purposes in the same cake project. Lindt’s recipe uses 70% dark chocolate in the cake and frosting and LINDOR truffles as decoration; custard creams are vanilla-filled sandwich biscuits.

    Choose the ingredient for the part of the recipe where you intend to use it, and do not swap in filled truffles for recipe-specified chocolate without instructions that call for that substitution.

  • Assuming every custard cream has the same dietary labelling

    Tesco’s standard custard creams contain wheat and milk ingredients, while Sainsbury’s labels its separate Free From Custard Creams product milk and gluten free. That biscuit label says nothing about the rest of a cake.

    Read the current pack and check the chocolate, frosting and other decorations separately when dietary restrictions matter.

  • Skipping the decoration’s allergen label

    Decorations become part of the served cake. The Joybuy listing for LINDOR Milk Chocolate Truffles lists barley, milk and soya and warns that the product may contain hazelnuts and other nuts.

    Check the exact truffle pack before using it, particularly when the cake will be shared.

Relevant biscuit brands

Tesco

Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits are 400 g vanilla-filled sandwich biscuits for a conventional custard-cream element.

  • A clearly identified biscuit option when the cake plan calls for custard creams.
  • Tesco lists wheat flour and whey powder (milk), with a possible-sesame warning. Check the current label.

Crawford's

Crawford's Custard Creams are 300 g sandwich biscuits with vanilla-flavour cream filling.

  • A conventional custard-cream biscuit choice for a biscuit element.
  • Tesco’s listing identifies wheat and milk ingredients; check the pack when those ingredients matter.

Sainsbury's

Sainsbury's lists conventional custard creams and a separate Free From Custard Creams product.

  • Sainsbury's labels its Free From Custard Creams milk and gluten free and suitable for coeliacs and vegans.
  • Those labels apply to that specific biscuit, not other biscuits or the completed cake. Read current packaging.

M&S

M&S Extra Cream Custard Creams use custard powder and a vanilla-cream filling.

  • An option to consider when choosing a custard-cream biscuit element.
  • M&S lists wheat, milk ingredients and soya lecithin for this product; check the current pack.

Joybuy product options

These options cover a custard-cream biscuit, dark chocolate to consider where a recipe calls for it, and boxed chocolates for a finished-cake decoration. Choose by the role needed in your cake plan.

Schar Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g

Schar Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g

A custard-cream biscuit option when the cake plan calls for a gluten-free biscuit element. Check the current pack for all dietary requirements and check the other cake ingredients separately; these biscuits do not replace recipe-specified chocolate.

View on Joybuy
Menier Dark Cooking Chocolate 70% Cocoa 100g

Menier Dark Cooking Chocolate 70% Cocoa 100g

A cooking-chocolate option to compare with a recipe that specifies 70% cocoa dark chocolate for the cake or frosting. Check the recipe’s required quantity and the current ingredient label; this is not a boxed truffle decoration.

View on Joybuy
Green & Black's Dark Chocolate 70% 90g

Green & Black's Dark Chocolate 70% 90g

A 70% dark chocolate bar to consider when that cocoa percentage matches the recipe. Check the required quantity, preparation instructions and current allergen label before using it in a cake or frosting.

View on Joybuy
Lindt LINDOR Dark 70% Cocoa 200g

Lindt LINDOR Dark 70% Cocoa 200g

Consider these LINDOR chocolates for a finished-cake decoration rather than as an automatic replacement for the chocolate specified in the bake. The product name states 70% cocoa; check the current pack for its contents and allergens.

View on Joybuy
Maltesers Truffles Giftbox with Malt Centre 200g

Maltesers Truffles Giftbox with Malt Centre 200g

A boxed-truffle option if the chocolates are intended for the finished cake or to accompany it as a gift. Its named malt-centre variant is distinct from a plain baking-chocolate bar; check the current pack before serving.

View on Joybuy

Common questions

Can boxed truffles replace baking chocolate in a cake?

Not as an automatic substitution. Lindt’s chocolate cake recipe specifies 70% dark chocolate for the cake and frosting, then uses LINDOR truffles to decorate the finished cake. Follow your recipe’s ingredient instructions unless it specifically calls for a different use.

Are ordinary custard creams suitable for a milk- or gluten-free cake?

Do not assume so: Tesco and M&S list wheat and milk ingredients in the standard products described here. Sainsbury's separately labels its Free From Custard Creams milk and gluten free, but the other cake ingredients and decorations need their own checks.

Do I need to check allergens in truffles used only as decoration?

Yes, because the decoration is part of the served cake. The Joybuy listing for LINDOR Milk Chocolate Truffles identifies barley, milk and soya and warns of possible hazelnuts and other nuts; read the exact product’s current label.

How should I store the biscuits and truffles before decorating?

Follow the current pack instructions. The custard-cream listings describe cool, dry storage, while the Joybuy listing for LINDOR Milk Chocolate Truffles says to store them in a dry place away from heat.