Hosts setting out one main sharing plate
A standard custard-cream sharing pack offers one biscuit style for the table. Asda suggests 34 servings from its 400g pack; use the number of guests and the other food you plan to serve to judge the quantity.
Who are you serving?
Hosts catering for dietary requirements
Standard custard creams listed by Tesco and Asda contain wheat and milk. Ask guests what they need to avoid, then choose a separately labelled product and keep its pack available for checking.
Guests who prefer biscuits without cream filling
McVitie's Original Digestives offer a plain, wholemeal-wheat alternative to a vanilla-cream sandwich biscuit. They are a different biscuit type, not a variety of custard cream.
What should you check before buying?
Choose the biscuit style your guests want, then check the pack quantity and the exact ingredients and allergen information.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Sharing quantity | Check pack weight and any suggested servings. Asda suggests 34 servings for its 400g standard custard creams; a 125g free-from pack calls for separate planning. | I'm putting out one main biscuit plate, so the pack needs to suit the number of guests rather than just the biscuit I prefer. |
| Biscuit style | Tesco describes its custard creams as sandwich biscuits with vanilla-flavour filling. McVitie's describes Original Digestives as having a salty-sweet wheat flavour and crunch. | A cream-filled biscuit would suit this table, or I could offer a plain digestive for guests who prefer one. |
| Ingredients and allergens | Read the exact pack, including its ingredients and may-contain statements. Tesco and Asda standard custard creams list wheat and milk; check a specifically labelled free-from product for guests' requirements. | Someone needs a biscuit that fits their dietary requirements, so I cannot assume the standard plate is suitable for them. |
| Nutrition labels | Keep per-biscuit and per-100g figures on their stated bases. Tesco lists 3.4g sugars per custard cream; McVitie's lists 2.2g per Original Digestive. The biscuits differ in recipe and size. | If I compare labels, I want the portion and other listed nutrients in view, not a verdict based on one sugar figure. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming every custard cream suits every guest
Tesco and Asda standard custard creams list wheat and milk. Their ingredient and may-contain statements also need checking against individual requirements.
Ask guests about requirements before buying. Keep a separately labelled option in its pack so its details remain available when you serve it.
-
Planning a small free-from pack like a sharing pack
Asda suggests 34 servings for its 400g standard custard creams, while its Free From custard creams come in a 125g pack. Those formats should not be treated as interchangeable quantities.
Work out the free-from quantity separately using the exact pack and the number of guests who need it.
If several guests need that option, one small pack may not be enough.
-
Judging digestives by sugar per biscuit alone
McVitie's lists 2.2g sugars and 71 kcal per Original Digestive; Tesco lists 3.4g sugars and 59 kcal per custard cream. Different recipes and biscuit sizes prevent a one-figure nutritional verdict.
Compare the complete labels on the same stated basis and choose the biscuit style guests actually want.
-
Relying on an old online ingredient list
Food ingredients and allergen information can change, so an earlier listing may not describe the pack you serve.
Check the current listing before ordering and read the delivered pack's ingredients, allergen statement and best-before date.
Relevant brand options
These examples show different biscuit styles and pack formats; a brand name alone does not establish the ingredients of a particular pack.
McVitie's
Original Digestives are the plain-biscuit alternative here. McVitie's describes their wholemeal-wheat flavour as salty-sweet.
- The Original Digestives label lists 2.2g sugars and 0.5g fibre per biscuit.
- Original Digestives contain gluten and may contain milk; they are not a free-from substitute.
Tesco
Tesco's 400g custard creams provide a standard sharing-pack format with vanilla-flavour filling.
- The pack is labelled as suitable for vegetarians.
- The product lists wheat and milk and may contain sesame; check the pack served.
Asda
Asda lists both 400g standard custard creams and a separate 125g Free From product.
- Asda suggests 34 servings for the 400g standard pack.
- The standard pack lists wheat and milk. Check the smaller Free From pack's own label for the requirements it meets.
Sainsbury's
Sainsbury's 200g custard creams are a smaller standard-pack option; its listing gives approximately 16 servings.
- The product is labelled as suitable for vegetarians.
- Its ingredients include wheat and milk-derived whey powder, and the listing says it is unsuitable for customers with a barley allergy.
M&S
M&S describes its 165g Extra Cream Custard Creams as having extra vanilla cream and custard powder.
- They offer a different filling style to consider alongside standard custard creams.
- The listed ingredients include wheat, milk and soya; check the exact pack before serving.
Schär
The Joybuy listing describes Schär Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g as gluten-free, lactose-free and vegan.
- This is a separately labelled custard-cream option for guests whose requirements match the pack.
- Lactose-free should not be treated as a substitute for checking the pack's full allergen statement.
Joybuy biscuit options
These two options cover different places on a coffee-morning table: plain digestives for guests who prefer a biscuit without cream filling, and a separately labelled custard-cream option for particular dietary requirements.
Image unavailable
McVitie's Original Digestives 2x315g
A plain digestive choice for guests who prefer a biscuit without cream filling. The twin pack contains 2x315g; Joybuy lists a typical 42 biscuits per pack. The product contains wheat and gluten and may contain milk, so check the pack against guests' requirements.
Image unavailable
Schär Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g
A separately labelled custard-cream option for guests whose requirements match the pack. Joybuy describes this 125g product as gluten-free, lactose-free and vegan. Plan the quantity separately from a larger sharing pack, and check the delivered pack's ingredients, allergen statement and any serving warnings.
Coffee-morning biscuit questions
Are custard creams and digestives the same biscuit?
No. Tesco describes its custard creams as sandwich biscuits with vanilla-flavour filling, while McVitie's Original Digestives are plain wholemeal-wheat biscuits. Offer both if guests would welcome those different styles.
How many custard creams should I buy for a group?
Start with your guest count and the serving guidance on the exact pack. Asda suggests 34 servings for its 400g standard custard creams; plan a smaller free-from pack separately if guests need that option.
Will standard custard creams suit guests avoiding gluten or milk?
Do not assume so: the standard Tesco and Asda products list wheat and milk. Asda separately labels its Free From custard creams as free from cereals containing gluten and milk, but check the current physical pack against each guest's requirements before serving.
Do digestives contain less sugar than custard creams?
For the specific products compared, McVitie's lists 2.2g sugars per Original Digestive and Tesco lists 3.4g per custard cream. That per-biscuit difference does not settle the choice: the biscuits have different recipes and sizes, so read the rest of each label on its stated basis too.