Families buying for home
If you are choosing a holiday biscuit to serve at home, compare the particular packs for flavour, portion size, nutrition and allergens rather than treating all digestives or custard creams alike.
Who is choosing the snacks?
School and holiday-club organisers in England
Food supplied through a school or Holiday Activities and Food (HAF) club raises a different question from a private household purchase. GOV.UK sets out food standards for maintained schools and academies in England; Coventry City Council's HAF provider guide says those standards also apply to snacks supplied at HAF clubs.
Families checking allergens
The compared McVitie's digestive contains wheat and may contain milk. Tesco's custard cream contains wheat and milk and may contain sesame seeds. Check the current packet for the biscuit you intend to serve, particularly when children share snacks.
What should you compare?
Decide first whether the biscuits are for home or an organised setting, then compare the exact packs for filling, nutrition, allergens and storage.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Nutrition label | Compare values on the same per-100g basis. McVitie's lists 15.1g sugars, 10.1g saturates and 3.7g fibre; Tesco lists 28.3g sugars, 12.8g saturates and 1.1g fibre for its custard creams. | I want to compare these two specific biscuits without assuming every digestive or custard cream has the same values. The figures come from McVitie's and Tesco product information. |
| Biscuit format | Check whether the pack is a plain digestive or a filled custard cream, and compare the serving information on the packs you are considering. | A vanilla-filled biscuit might be the preference at home; on another occasion, a plain digestive might be what the family wants. |
| Allergens | Read the current ingredients and precautionary statements. McVitie's The Original Digestives contain wheat and may contain milk; Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits contain wheat and milk and may contain sesame seeds. | When food will be shared, I need to check the actual packet for each child's relevant allergens before serving. |
| Setting | Establish who supplies the snack. GOV.UK says food served in maintained schools and academies in England must meet school food standards; Coventry City Council's HAF provider guide includes snacks supplied at HAF clubs. | If I am ordering for a school or HAF club, I need to confirm the setting's requirements rather than rely on a decision made for snacks at home. |
| Storage | Follow the pack instructions. Tesco advises keeping its custard creams in a cool, dry place and transferring them to an airtight container once opened; McVitie's advises a cool, dry place for its Original Digestives. | For a pack opened over several days, I want a way to store the remaining biscuits as directed. |
What is easy to overlook?
-
Judging nutrition by the word ‘digestive’
The McVitie's digestive has less sugar and more fibre per 100g than the Tesco custard cream in this comparison, but its name does not describe every value on its nutrition panel.
Compare the specific packs on a per-100g basis, then use their serving information when deciding how much to put out.
-
Using a home-snack choice for a club menu
A biscuit chosen for private use has not thereby been cleared for food supplied by a school or HAF club in England. GOV.UK sets out school food standards, and Coventry City Council's HAF provider guide includes snacks.
Confirm the applicable requirements with the school or club before ordering food for its activities.
-
Treating custard creams as identical
Tesco lists 28.3g sugars and 12.8g saturates per 100g for its custard creams; M&S lists 40.2g sugars and 13.5g saturates per 100g for Extra Cream Custard Creams. Those figures describe the named products, not the whole category.
Check the label again when changing product or recipe, including its allergens and serving information.
-
Relying on an earlier allergen listing
The compared biscuits have different ingredient and precautionary allergen statements, so a familiar-looking replacement is not necessarily equivalent for someone managing an allergy.
Read the physical packet immediately before serving, and repeat the check when substituting a product.
Relevant product lines
These references concern the named biscuits and their labels, not every product made by each brand.
McVitie's
The Original Digestives are the plain digestive in this label comparison.
- McVitie's lists 15.1g sugars, 10.1g saturates and 3.7g fibre per 100g.
- The product contains wheat and may contain milk; check the current pack where either allergen matters.
Tesco
Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits are the classic filled biscuit in this comparison.
- Tesco lists 28.3g sugars, 12.8g saturates and 1.1g fibre per 100g, allowing a like-for-like label comparison.
- The biscuits contain wheat and milk and may contain sesame seeds.
M&S
Extra Cream Custard Creams provide another filled-biscuit label to compare.
- M&S lists 40.2g sugars and 13.5g saturates per 100g for this product.
- Those values differ from Tesco's custard creams; inspect the exact pack rather than carrying one product's figures over to another.
Joybuy biscuit options
These options include plain digestive varieties and a gluten-free custard cream. Use each product's current label to make the same nutrition and allergen checks you would make for a biscuit bought elsewhere.
No image available
McVitie's Digestives the Original 2x315g
A plain digestive option for snacks at home. The Joybuy listing gives 15.1g sugars and 3.7g fibre per 100g for this 2x315g pack. Check the physical pack's ingredients and allergen statement before serving.
No image available
Schar Gluten Free Custard Creams 125g
A custard cream option for shoppers looking at gluten-free varieties. If buying for someone with an allergy or intolerance, confirm the current pack's ingredients and precautionary statements rather than relying on the product name alone.
No image available
Gullon Zero Sugar Free Original Digestives 400g
A differently formulated digestive to consider alongside the original variety. Compare the current nutrition panel, ingredients, sweetener information and any pack warnings before deciding whether it meets your needs.
Common questions
Can I use the same biscuit choice for home and a school-holiday club?
Not without checking the club's requirements. A private purchase for home is different from food supplied by an organised provider: GOV.UK says food served in maintained schools and academies in England must meet school food standards, and Coventry City Council's HAF provider guide says HAF club snacks must meet those standards. Neither rule establishes that every custard cream or digestive is automatically permitted or prohibited.
Which of the compared biscuits lists less sugar?
McVitie's The Original Digestives list 15.1g sugars per 100g, against 28.3g per 100g for Tesco Custard Cream Biscuits, according to their product information. Compare other brands and variants by their own labels rather than applying this result to every biscuit of either type.
What should I check if a child has a wheat, milk or sesame allergy?
Read the physical packet before serving. The compared McVitie's digestives contain wheat and may contain milk; Tesco's custard creams contain wheat and milk and may contain sesame seeds. Do not assume that another variant has the same ingredients or precautionary statements.
How should I keep an opened pack?
Follow the instructions on the particular pack. Tesco advises storing its custard creams in a cool, dry place and using an airtight container once opened; McVitie's advises a cool, dry place for its Original Digestives.