Hosts serving a larger party
A scoopable tub lets guests help themselves. Waitrose and Tesco list 2-litre options, while the menu and guest count determine whether one tub is enough.
Who is each format for?
Hosts planning a dessert course
Several smaller tubs allow a choice of flavours. Check the volume of each one if guests are likely to want the same flavour.
Hosts serving guests with dietary restrictions
A separately labelled dairy-free option can sit alongside dairy desserts. Read each current pack’s ingredients and allergy advice, and use separate serving utensils where needed.
What should you check before choosing?
Settle on the serving format first, then check pack volume, dietary labels and the space available in your freezer.
One large tub
Choose when: guests can scoop from a shared tub and one flavour suits the menu.
Trade-off: you will need bowls and a clean scoop, and one dairy tub will not cover guests who avoid milk.
Several smaller tubs
Choose when: a smaller gathering wants flavour choice or a separately labelled dairy-free dessert.
Trade-off: check that there is enough of each flavour for the guests who want it.
Individual portions
Choose when: you want to count servings without scooping from a shared tub.
Trade-off: portion count does not establish dietary suitability; check every product label.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | Compare tub volumes with the guest count and any other desserts. Check the displayed price per litre when comparing tubs by value. | I’m serving dessert from a shared table and need enough for the guests who will want a scoop. |
| Choice | Check each flavour and pack size. For dairy avoidance, look for an explicit dairy-free or vegan label and read the ingredients. | Some guests may want different flavours, while others need an option separate from dairy desserts. |
| Allergens | Read the current ingredients and may-contain statements for each product. Keep utensils separate where guests need to avoid particular allergens. | Before anyone helps themselves, I need to know which dessert and serving utensil they can use. |
| Storage and serving | Check freezer space, the pack’s storage temperature and any thawing or refreezing instructions. For individual desserts, count the portions in each pack. | I want dessert ready to serve when guests arrive, without leaving frozen products out longer than their instructions allow. |
What can go wrong when planning dessert?
-
Expecting a small tub to serve like a large one
A 420–500ml tub provides substantially less volume than a 2-litre tub listed by UK grocers. At a self-serve table, a popular flavour could run out sooner than planned.
Choose the amount of scoopable dessert around your guest count and the rest of the menu; add a smaller flavour only where it serves a purpose.
-
Judging dairy-free suitability by flavour
A fruit flavour or dessert name does not establish whether a product contains milk.
Look for an explicit dairy-free designation and read the ingredients and allergy statement on the exact pack.
-
Overlooking allergy advice at a shared serving table
The Food Standards Agency identifies milk as an allergen, and individual frozen desserts can carry additional allergen declarations or may-contain warnings.
Check each pack with guests’ requirements in mind, and use separate scoops or tongs for desserts intended to remain separate.
-
Letting dessert thaw before the party
Storage and refreezing directions matter: the Mackie's product listed by Asda says to keep it frozen and not refreeze it after thawing.
Put frozen purchases into the freezer promptly and follow each pack’s own storage and serving instructions.
Relevant retailers and brands
M&S Food
M&S Food lists smaller Collection tubs, a 785g soft-scoop ice cream and Plant Kitchen options.
- Different formats can help when a party menu needs more than one dessert choice.
- Compare pack quantities before treating a smaller tub as a substitute for a large sharing tub.
Waitrose
Waitrose lists a 2-litre Essential Vanilla Soft Scoop tub as well as a separately labelled 750ml Swedish Glace dairy-free vegan tub.
- The listed formats provide distinct options for volume and dairy-free provision.
- Check the volume and label of each product rather than assuming the tubs serve the same need.
Tesco
Tesco lists 2-litre Tesco Cornish and Mackie's dairy ice creams alongside smaller tubs.
- The listed sizes allow hosts to compare a large sharing format with smaller flavour choices.
- Check current pack details when planning the quantity for your gathering.
Asda
Asda has a family-sized ice-cream-tub category and lists a 1-litre Mackie's Honeycomb dairy ice cream.
- The family-sized category offers a place to check larger formats.
- Asda’s Mackie's product listing declares milk and warns that it may contain nuts and peanuts; check the exact pack for guests with allergies.
Häagen-Dazs
Tesco and Waitrose list Häagen-Dazs in smaller tubs and mini-cup formats.
- These formats can add flavour choice or individually served desserts to a smaller gathering.
- Check the quantity and allergen information for the particular flavour or collection.
Joybuy frozen-dessert options
These options include scoopable tubs in different sizes and flavours, including a smaller plant-based choice. Compare their pack quantities and current labels against your party menu.
No image available
Kulfi Ice Original Malai Tub 1L
A 1L scoopable tub for a shared dessert table. It contains milk; check the current pack’s allergy advice before serving.
No image available
XO ICE Plant-Based Mango and Coconut Gelato 473ml
A smaller, plant-based tub to consider as a separate choice alongside dairy desserts. It contains coconut and may contain traces of eggs, peanuts, sesame and tree nuts; check the current pack.
No image available
Carte D'Or Indulgent Chocolate Ice Cream Dessert 900ml
A 900ml chocolate dessert tub for scooping as part of a party menu. It contains milk and has additional may-contain advice; read the current pack for guests with allergies.
No image available
Nutella Ice Cream Tub 470ml
A smaller tub for adding another flavour rather than relying on one tub for a larger gathering. It contains hazelnuts, milk and soya; check the current pack for further allergy advice.
No image available
Mackies Honeycomb Harvest Ice Cream 1 Litre
A 1-litre honeycomb ice cream tub for scooping. It contains milk and may contain nuts and peanuts. Check the pack’s freezer directions before buying and follow them when storing it.
Frozen-dessert questions
How much frozen dessert should I buy for a New Year's Eve party?
Start with the number of guests likely to have dessert and whether you are also serving cake, fruit or other sweets. A 1.8–2 litre tub is a format to consider for a larger scoopable buffet; several smaller tubs offer more flavour choice for a smaller group. There is no fixed serving count without knowing your menu and portions.
Should I choose one large tub or several smaller ones?
Choose a large tub when volume and simple self-service matter more than flavour choice. Smaller tubs make more sense when you want different flavours or a separately labelled dairy-free option; compare their actual volumes before deciding how many to buy.
Which allergens should I check?
Read the ingredients and may-contain advice on every current pack. The Food Standards Agency identifies milk as an allergen, and the listed frozen desserts show that warnings for nuts, peanuts, egg or soya can vary by product. Keep serving utensils separate where guests need to avoid particular allergens.
How should I store frozen desserts before serving?
Follow each pack’s freezer and refreezing instructions, and put frozen purchases into the freezer promptly. GOV.UK food-hygiene guidance says frozen food should go into the freezer as soon as it is delivered; the Mackie's tub listed by Asda specifies −18°C and says not to refreeze after thawing.