Two diners planning a shared fakeaway
A larger loaded or stuffed-crust pizza is an option when you both want the same topping. If you would rather choose separately, two thin pizzas let each person have a different one.
Who is each format for?
Diners with different toppings or dietary requirements
Separate pizzas make it easier to choose different recipes. Dr. Oetker lists vegan and gluten-free pizzas alongside standard Ristorante products, but each person still needs to check the exact pack for ingredients and allergens.
Shoppers with limited freezer space
Check the dimensions of the pizzas against the space available before buying for another night. Pack weight and stated servings also help you decide whether one shared pizza or two separate ones fit your meal plan.
What should you check before choosing?
Decide whether you want to share a topping or choose separately, then check the exact packs for portions, cooking directions and allergens.
Two separate pizzas
Choose when: You want different toppings or need to select different dietary variants.
Allow for: Two pizzas may need separate oven space or staggered cooking.
One larger pizza to share
Choose when: Both diners want the same topping and a shared pizza.
Allow for: A large pizza is not necessarily labelled as two servings, and a stuffed crust may need a rest before cutting.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Portions | Compare pack weight, stated servings and nutrition per serving. Tesco labels the 532g Goodfella's New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni as two servings; Sainsbury's lists a 640g Chicago Town stuffed-crust pepperoni pizza as four. | I want to know how the amount we plan to eat compares with the pack's stated serving size. |
| Crust and toppings | Check whether the base is thin, stonebaked or stuffed, and whether both diners want the same topping. A range name does not establish the ingredients of every variant. | A crisp thin pizza appeals to me, but the other diner may want a different topping or crust. |
| Cooking | Read the exact pack for oven setting, tray or shelf position and cooking time. Dr. Oetker gives 10–13 minutes for Ristorante Mozzarella; Chicago Town gives 18–23 minutes in a fan oven for its 640g cheese-stuffed-crust loaded pepperoni pizza. | We need a pizza that fits our oven and the time available to cook it as directed. |
| Ingredients | Check each variant's ingredient list, allergen statement and any dietary claim. Dr. Oetker's Quattro Formaggi lists wheat, milk and soybeans; its separately named vegan and gluten-free products are different variants. | One of us may need a different recipe, so I cannot rely on the brand name alone. |
| Storage | Check that the packs fit your freezer and follow their storage instructions. GOV.UK advises keeping a freezer around −18°C and following food-label freezing and defrosting directions. | If plans change, I need room to keep the pizzas frozen as directed. |
What is easy to overlook?
-
Assuming every large pizza is labelled for two
Serving declarations differ: Tesco lists two servings for the 532g Goodfella's New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni, while Sainsbury's lists four for a 640g Chicago Town stuffed-crust pepperoni pizza.
Read the serving declaration, total weight and nutrition panel on the pizza you choose before dividing it between two.
-
Assuming a whole range has the same allergen profile
Ingredients vary by recipe. Joybuy lists milk and wheat for Goodfella's Pepperoni Stonebaked Thin, while its Dr. Oetker Quattro Formaggi listing also names soybeans.
Check the current ingredient and allergen information on the exact pack, including any may-contain statement.
-
Using the same oven timing for every crust
Dr. Oetker lists 10–13 minutes for Ristorante Mozzarella, whereas Chicago Town gives its 640g cheese-stuffed-crust loaded pepperoni pizza 18–23 minutes in a fan oven and directs a two-minute rest.
Follow the chosen pack's oven setting, placement, rotation and cooking directions. Take care when cutting or eating hot toppings and filled crusts.
Which brands and ranges are relevant?
Goodfella's
Its cited products include a 332g Pepperoni Stonebaked Thin pizza and a 532g New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni pizza labelled as two servings by Tesco.
- The two formats offer a choice between buying separate thin pizzas and sharing one larger pepperoni pizza.
- For the 532g New York Style pizza, Tesco lists 13g saturates and 3.3g salt per half pizza; check the serving basis when comparing nutrition panels.
Dr. Oetker
Its Ristorante range includes thin pizzas and separately named vegan and gluten-free variants.
- Dr. Oetker lists its 335g Ristorante Mozzarella pizza as thin and crispy, with a 10–13 minute cooking guide.
- Check the exact variant: its Quattro Formaggi pizza lists wheat, milk and soybeans.
Chicago Town
The range includes takeaway-style and deep-dish formats for diners considering a shared pizza.
- Chicago Town describes its 640g Takeaway Cheese Stuffed Crust Loaded Pepperoni with rising dough and a cheese-filled crust.
- Its instructions specify 18–23 minutes in a fan oven, rotation during cooking and a two-minute rest; the brand warns that the topping and filled crust will be extremely hot.
Tesco
Tesco's frozen-pizza listings include own-label pizzas and branded thin-crust products.
- Its Goodfella's New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni listing states the pack weight, two-serving basis and nutrition per half pizza.
- Use the details for the exact listed product rather than applying one pizza's serving declaration to another.
Sainsbury's
Its frozen-pizza listings include own-label thin and deep-pan pizzas alongside branded individual and large formats.
- Its listing for a 640g Chicago Town stuffed-crust pepperoni pizza states that one pizza serves four people.
- Check each product's serving declaration separately when planning a meal for two.
Asda
Asda lists the 532g Goodfella's New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni pizza with product-specific ingredients and nutrition.
- The listing gives nutrition per half pizza, which can be read alongside its stated portion.
- Check the exact product and current pack when comparing ingredients or allergens.
Frozen pizza options on Joybuy
These options include pizzas labelled as two servings, stuffed-crust pizzas described for sharing and a stonebaked-thin pizza that can be chosen as one of two separate pizzas.
Image unavailable
Dr. Oetker Ristorante Pepperoni Salame Pizza 320g
The product description labels this thin-and-crispy pizza as serving two. It gives a 10–13 minute cooking guide with rotation halfway through. It contains wheat and milk; check the current pack for its complete allergen statement.
Image unavailable
Chicago Town Takeaway Stuffed Crust Sweet Honey BBQ Salami Pizza 635g
This stuffed-crust pizza is described for sharing and has honey BBQ sauce, salami and onions. Its cooking guide is 20–22 minutes from frozen. Check the pack's serving declaration before splitting it between two; it contains wheat and may contain soy and mustard.
Image unavailable
Chicago Town Stuffed Crust Takeaway Loaded Cheese 630g
The description presents this four-cheese stuffed-crust pizza as one to share. It specifies a baking tray and an 18–22 minute cooking window. Check the pack's stated servings; it contains milk and wheat and may contain mustard and soy.
Image unavailable
Pizza Express American 320g
This tomato, mozzarella and pepperoni pizza is described as containing two servings. Check the pack for its oven setting, placement and cooking time. It contains wheat and milk and may contain soya and mustard.
Image unavailable
Goodfella's Pepperoni Stonebaked Thin 332g
This pepperoni pizza offers a stonebaked-thin option if the diners are choosing separate pizzas. Check the pack for its serving declaration and exact oven directions. It contains milk and wheat; read the current pack for complete allergen information.
Questions about frozen pizza for two
Is one large frozen pizza enough for two people?
It depends on the particular pizza and the portions you plan to serve. Tesco labels the 532g Goodfella's New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni as two servings, while Sainsbury's lists a 640g Chicago Town stuffed-crust pepperoni pizza as four. Check the chosen pack's servings, weight and nutrition panel.
Should we buy two pizzas or one to share?
Choose two separate pizzas if you want different toppings or need different dietary variants. One larger pizza is an option when you both want the same topping; check its stated servings and make sure it fits your oven before choosing it.
Should frozen pizza be defrosted before cooking?
Follow the directions on the exact pack rather than defrosting it by default. Goodfella's directs its New York Style Loaded Pepperoni pizza to be cooked from frozen, and GOV.UK advises following food-label freezing and defrosting instructions.
How should I store a frozen pizza?
Keep it frozen according to its pack instructions. GOV.UK advises a freezer temperature of around −18°C; follow the product label if your plans change or the pizza thaws.
Does a vegan or gluten-free pizza suit every dietary requirement?
No: check the exact variant's current ingredients, allergen statement and dietary claim. Dr. Oetker lists separately named vegan and gluten-free pizzas, while its Quattro Formaggi product lists wheat, milk and soybeans.