What should you check before choosing?
Decide what job each pizza will do, then check physical fit, the current allergen label and the cooking directions for both packs.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
| Freezer fit |
Compare both box dimensions with the space available. Follow each pack’s frozen-storage instructions; Goodfella’s specifies −18°C for its Stonebaked Thin Margherita. |
I need room for two pizzas without displacing the rest of the freezer shop. In the British Frozen Food Federation and Vypr’s October 2024 UK findings, 85% of consumers said insufficient freezer space limited their frozen-food purchases. |
| Meal roles |
Compare format, stated pack weight and toppings rather than assuming two pizzas will serve the same purpose. A 295g Dr. Oetker vegan pizza and Chicago Town’s 640g stuffed-crust meat pizza illustrate different pack choices, not a fixed serving rule. |
One pizza might accompany curry night; another needs to work as a separate main meal. Different toppings also give the household a choice on another evening. |
| Dietary fit |
Read each current ingredient list, highlighted allergens and any relevant free-from claim. Dr. Oetker warns that its Ristorante Vegan Pepperoni-Salame may contain traces of milk constituents. |
If someone has a milk allergy, I cannot use a vegan label as a substitute for checking that exact pack. A vegetarian or meat-free choice may meet a different need. |
| Cooking |
Check the appliance, temperature, time and tray directions for each SKU. Dr. Oetker lists 10–12 minutes for its Vegan Pepperoni-Salame in a fan oven at 200°C; Chicago Town lists 16–20 minutes at 180°C for its 640g Takeaway BBQ Stuffed Crust Magnificent Meat Feast. |
With curry and sides being prepared too, I need to know whether the oven schedule works for the pizza I actually buy. |
Brand ranges worth comparing
These ranges provide different formats to consider; the ingredients and directions of a named pizza do not apply automatically to every product from its brand.
Goodfella’s
Goodfella’s lists thin-crust, takeaway-style, deep-pan and gluten-free frozen-pizza ranges. Its Stonebaked Thin Margherita is a meat-free choice to compare with a meat-topped second pizza.
- A thin Margherita offers a different format from a stuffed-crust pizza.
- The Stonebaked Thin Margherita contains wheat and milk. Goodfella’s says to store it frozen at −18°C and not refreeze it after defrosting.
Chicago Town
Chicago Town lists Takeaway stuffed-crust and Deep Dish formats. Its 640g Takeaway BBQ Stuffed Crust Magnificent Meat Feast is an example to consider when one pizza is intended as a main-meal backup.
- The named pizza has a stuffed crust and meat toppings.
- Chicago Town gives it a 16–20-minute fan-oven time or 21–23 minutes in a conventional oven, with a baking tray and halfway rotation.
Dr. Oetker Ristorante
The Ristorante range includes vegan pizzas. Its 295g Vegan Pepperoni-Salame is a plant-based option to compare with a larger conventional pizza.
- Dr. Oetker states a 10–12-minute cook time for this pizza in either a 200°C fan oven or a 220°C conventional oven.
- The same product may contain traces of milk constituents; check its current allergen statement if that matters to an eater.
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference
Sainsbury’s lists a 400g Mozzarella & Marinated Cherry Tomato Wood Fired Pizza on a sourdough base for a planned oven meal.
- The listed toppings include mozzarella and cherry tomatoes.
- Sainsbury’s gives a 15–17-minute oven time from frozen. Check the current pack’s allergen information before serving it.
Tesco
Tesco’s frozen-pizza listings include own-label and Tesco Finest products, providing another range to consider during a supermarket freezer shop.
- A Tesco listing identifies a Stonebaked Thin BBQ Meat Feast Pizza 340g.
- Check the current product label for ingredients, dietary details and cooking instructions before choosing it as part of a pair.
Joybuy pizza options
These options include stuffed-crust pizzas for a main-meal backup and thin-base pizzas that could provide a contrasting second choice. Check the two boxes together against your freezer space and the eaters’ needs.
No image available
Chicago Town Takeaway Stuffed Crust Sweet Honey BBQ Salami Pizza 635g
Consider this 635g salami pizza when one box is intended as a stuffed-crust main-meal backup. Check its box dimensions, cooking directions and current allergen label before pairing it with another pizza.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Chicago Town Stuffed Crust Takeaway Loaded Cheese 630g
This 630g stuffed-crust cheese pizza offers a meat-free topping choice in a substantial format. Check the current allergen label, cooking instructions and box dimensions for the planned meal.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Chicago Town Takeaway Stuffed Crust BBQ Chicken with BBQ Sauce Filled Crust 668g
For a meat-topped main-meal option, this 668g pizza has a BBQ sauce-filled stuffed crust. Read its own cooking panel before fitting it into a curry-night oven schedule, and check that the box fits your freezer.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Goodfella’s Margherita Stonebaked Thin 334g
This 334g thin-base Margherita can provide a meat-free contrast to a meat-topped pizza. Its cheese topping is not suitable for someone avoiding milk; check the current pack for allergens, cooking directions and freezer fit.
View on Joybuy
No image available
Goodfella’s Pepperoni Stonebaked Thin 332g
This 332g thin-base pepperoni pizza offers a meat-topped alternative to a Margherita. Check the current pack for its cooking time and allergens, and compare the box dimensions with the space left for a second pizza.
View on Joybuy
Questions about storing and cooking pizza
Should the two frozen pizzas be identical?
Not if you want one as a curry-night accompaniment and another as a main-meal backup. A thin, meat-free pizza and a substantial stuffed-crust pizza cover those different roles, provided both suit the eaters and fit in the freezer. Two of the same pizza can still make sense if both are intended for the same meal.
How should I store the pizzas after shopping?
Follow each product’s storage instructions. Goodfella’s says to keep its Stonebaked Thin Margherita frozen at −18°C and not refreeze it after defrosting; check the other pizza’s pack rather than assuming its directions are identical.
Is a vegan pizza suitable for someone with a milk allergy?
Do not assume so: Dr. Oetker’s Ristorante Vegan Pepperoni-Salame says it may contain traces of milk constituents. Check the exact product’s current allergen statement and any relevant free-from claim; GOV.UK distinguishes a claim about the absence of a specified allergen from an ordinary dietary description.
Which allergen details should I check on a frozen-pizza pack?
Check the ingredient list, highlighted allergens and any precautionary or free-from wording against the eater’s needs. GOV.UK says that any of the 14 regulated allergens present as ingredients in prepacked food must be clearly identified in the ingredients list.
Can I microwave a frozen pizza instead of oven-cooking it?
Only when the exact product gives microwave directions. Chicago Town provides microwave instructions for its Deep Dish Mega Meaty, one pizza at a time, while its Takeaway BBQ Stuffed Crust Magnificent Meat Feast has oven directions. Check the pack of the pizza you buy.