Hosts feeding a mixed group
Choose two distinct toppings or formats so guests have a meaningful choice, then check whether both pizzas fit your oven and serving plan.
Who is choosing the pizzas?
Hosts planning portions in advance
Compare pack weights and stated servings before deciding whether two pizzas will cover the people coming over. A large sharing pizza and a smaller thin-base pizza will not necessarily provide the same number of portions.
Hosts accommodating a dietary requirement
Confirm the guest’s requirement before choosing a vegetarian, vegan or gluten-free pizza. Read the current ingredients and allergen statements on the exact pack; those labels answer different questions.
What should you check before buying?
Decide who each pizza must serve, then check portions, cooking instructions and dietary suitability for both packs.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Portions | Compare pack weight and stated servings. Sainsbury’s lists the 630g Chicago Town cheese pizza per quarter; ASDA lists the 532g Goodfella’s pepperoni pizza per half. | I need to know how many people the two pizzas must feed, rather than assuming each pack provides the same number of portions. |
| Crust and toppings | Check whether the second pizza offers a different topping or base. Chicago Town’s researched cheese pizza has a stuffed crust; Dr. Oetker describes Ristorante Pollo as thin and crispy. | A different style would give guests a choice instead of leaving us with two similar pizzas. |
| Oven timing | Read each pack’s time, temperature and shelf instructions. Goodfella’s UK & IE states 19–20 minutes for its loaded pepperoni pizza; Dr. Oetker UK states 11–13 minutes for Ristorante Pollo, using its own oven settings. | I want to plan when each pizza goes in so they can be served during the match. |
| Dietary fit | Check the exact product’s designation, ingredients and precautionary allergen statements. Dr. Oetker UK says its gluten-free Mozzarella pizza contains milk proteins, while its Vegan Pepperoni-Salame may contain traces of milk constituents. | If a guest has a particular dietary requirement or allergy, I need a pizza that meets that requirement—not just a label that sounds similar. |
| Nutrition basis | Compare figures using the stated portion size. Sainsbury’s lists 449 kcal, 11g saturates and 1.8g salt per quarter of the Chicago Town cheese pizza; ASDA lists 705 kcal, 13g saturates and 3.3g salt per half of the Goodfella’s pepperoni pizza. | I want to read each nutrition panel against the portion people are likely to serve, without comparing a quarter pizza directly with a half. |
What can catch you out?
-
Treating dietary labels as interchangeable
A vegan label does not establish suitability for a milk allergy. Dr. Oetker UK says its Vegan Pepperoni-Salame may contain traces of milk constituents, while its gluten-free Mozzarella pizza contains milk proteins.
Ask what the guest needs, then check the current ingredients, allergen declaration and precautionary statements on the exact pack.
-
Assuming every pizza provides the same portions
Pack sizes and nutrition serving bases differ: Sainsbury’s lists the 630g Chicago Town cheese pizza per quarter, while ASDA lists the 532g Goodfella’s pepperoni pizza per half.
Work out how many guests each pizza must cover, then compare the pack weights and stated servings.
-
Using one cooking plan for both pizzas
The manufacturers give different instructions: Goodfella’s UK & IE states 19–20 minutes for its loaded pepperoni pizza, while Dr. Oetker UK states 11–13 minutes for Ristorante Pollo.
Read both packs before cooking, use each product’s oven settings and check that the food is piping hot before serving, as the Food Standards Agency advises.
Which brands offer relevant formats?
Goodfella’s
Goodfella’s UK & IE presents its Takeaway range as stone-baked pizzas with loaded toppings for a night in.
- Its New York Style Fully Loaded Pepperoni pizza is a 532g option; the manufacturer states a 19–20 minute oven time.
- ASDA lists milk and wheat allergens and gives nutrition per half pizza for that specific product. Check the pack for all guests’ requirements.
Chicago Town
Chicago Town’s range includes stuffed-crust and deep-dish formats. Its researched Cheesy Stuffed Cheese pizza offers a meat-free sharing route.
- Sainsbury’s lists the 630g Cheesy Stuffed Cheese pizza as suitable for vegetarians, with a cheese-filled crust.
- That product contains wheat and milk. Sainsbury’s states its nutrition per quarter pizza, so check the portion basis when comparing packs.
Dr. Oetker Ristorante
Dr. Oetker UK describes Ristorante as a thin-and-crispy range that includes conventional, vegan and gluten-free products.
- Dr. Oetker UK states an 11–13 minute oven time for Ristorante Pollo, making its stated cooking window different from the researched Goodfella’s loaded pepperoni pizza.
- The gluten-free Mozzarella product contains milk proteins, and Vegan Pepperoni-Salame may contain traces of milk constituents. Check the exact pack against the guest’s needs.
Sainsbury’s
Sainsbury’s own-label Takeaway Stuffed Crust Pepperoni pizza is another stuffed-crust format to consider for meat-eating guests.
- The retailer lists a 424g pack with a 14–16 minute cook-from-frozen instruction.
- Sainsbury’s says this product is not suitable for customers with a celery allergy because of its manufacturing methods.
Frozen pizza options on Joybuy
These options include larger stuffed-crust pizzas with cheese, meat or chicken toppings, plus a smaller thin-base cheese pizza. Choose the pair by the guests’ preferences and the information on each current pack.
No image available
Chicago Town Stuffed Crust Takeaway Loaded Cheese 630g
A 630g cheese-topped stuffed-crust option when you want one larger pizza without a meat topping. Check the current pack if a guest requires a vegetarian designation or has a milk or wheat allergy.
No image available
Chicago Town Takeaway BBQ Stuffed Magnificent Meat Feast Pizza 640g
A 640g meat-topped stuffed-crust option for guests who want a different topping from a cheese pizza. It is not a meat-free choice; check the current pack for wheat, milk and other relevant allergen statements.
No image available
Chicago Town Takeaway Stuffed Crust Sweet Honey BBQ Salami Pizza 635g
A 635g stuffed-crust option if the group wants salami and a sweet honey BBQ topping. Check the current pack carefully for allergies: the listed ingredients include cheese, but the accompanying allergen declaration does not name milk.
No image available
Chicago Town Takeaway Stuffed Crust BBQ Chicken with BBQ Sauce Filled Crust 668g
A 668g chicken-topped stuffed-crust option for a group that prefers BBQ flavours. Check the pack’s cooking time before planning when to serve it, and read its wheat and milk allergen information against guests’ requirements.
No image available
Goodfella’s Margherita Stonebaked Thin 334g
A 334g thin-base cheese pizza if you want a different format from the larger stuffed-crust options. Check its stated servings and cooking time on the pack; confirm its designation if a guest requires a vegetarian product, and check its milk and gluten information.
Questions about stocking two pizzas
Should I buy two identical pizzas for football night?
Two different pizzas give a mixed group more choice. Consider a larger sharing pizza alongside a different topping or crust; if a guest has a confirmed dietary requirement, choose the second pizza against the exact pack information instead.
How should I plan the cooking?
Read both packs before the match and plan around each pizza’s stated temperature and time. Goodfella’s UK & IE gives 19–20 minutes for its loaded pepperoni pizza, while Dr. Oetker UK gives 11–13 minutes for Ristorante Pollo. Follow the individual instructions and check that the food is piping hot before serving.
Is a vegan pizza suitable for someone with a milk allergy?
Do not rely on the vegan designation alone. Dr. Oetker UK says its Ristorante Vegan Pepperoni-Salame may contain traces of milk constituents. Check the current pack’s ingredients and precautionary statement against the affected guest’s requirements.
What should I check before storing two pizzas?
Make sure both packs will fit in the freezer and follow each product’s storage instructions. Goodfella’s UK & IE specifies storage at −18°C for its researched pizza and says not to refreeze it after defrosting; check the instructions on whichever pizzas you buy.