Who needs to make this choice?

Households using several devices at once

If streaming, gaming, studying and video calls coincide, work out whether the broadband connection or the in-home network is limiting use. Ofcom advises checking what other devices are doing on the connection.

Households with weak Wi-Fi in particular rooms

Note where the signal becomes unreliable before choosing equipment. Ofcom’s Wi-Fi guidance makes the broadband service a separate consideration; Which? distinguishes targeted extension from wider mesh coverage.

People considering their own router

Check the exact provider and broadband access type before replacing a hub. EE specifies PPPoE support for its network, while TalkTalk says a non-TalkTalk router needs manually entered connection settings.

What should you check first?

Start with the scope of the problem, then choose between a wired device connection, targeted coverage equipment and a change to the main router.

PriorityWhat to checkYour needs
Service or Wi-Fi? Check provider status and which devices are affected. Compare a direct Ethernet connection with Wi-Fi where practical; Ofcom says Wi-Fi cannot outperform the broadband service. Everything is slow, or just devices in certain rooms? I want to know which problem I am addressing before buying coverage equipment.
Coverage Check hub placement and locate the weak areas. Which? describes an extender as the simpler option for a targeted area and mesh as a wider, whole-home route. One room needs attention, or several rooms and floors do. The pattern matters more to me than a coverage claim on a box.
Simultaneous use Check whether problems coincide with other data-heavy tasks. For a fixed device, check whether a cable and the required Ethernet ports or adapter are practical; a wired connection avoids that device’s Wi-Fi link. Video calls or games become unreliable when others are online. I can wire up a stationary device if the cable route works in my home.
Provider compatibility Identify the broadband access type and ask for the provider’s own-router settings. EE specifies PPPoE support; TalkTalk requires manual settings for non-TalkTalk routers, and Plusnet says a router must be compatible with its network. If I replace the hub, I need the new router to connect to my particular service, not merely carry a general compatibility claim.
Connected services Check whether the hub serves a digital landline or other dependent equipment before reconfiguring it. Ofcom says a digital landline works through the broadband router. Our home phone or connected support equipment must be considered before I change how the hub is connected.
Ongoing upkeep Check how the device receives firmware updates and how to administer it. The National Cyber Security Centre says firmware updates deliver bug fixes and security updates. I want networking equipment I can keep updated and manage after installation.

What can go wrong when changing equipment?

  • Buying mesh before checking the broadband connection

    A service fault or slow broadband connection can remain after a Wi-Fi upgrade. Ofcom notes that Wi-Fi cannot outperform the broadband service.

    Check provider status and compare a wired connection where practical. Note whether all devices are affected or the problem is confined to distant rooms.

  • Assuming any retail router will connect to your provider

    Connection requirements depend on the provider and service type. EE specifies PPPoE support, TalkTalk requires manual settings for a non-TalkTalk router, and Plusnet requires a compatible router.

    Identify your access type and check your provider’s own-router instructions against the exact model before buying.

  • Changing an ISP hub’s mode without reviewing the setup

    Virgin Media describes modem mode as turning its Hub into a cable modem for your own Wi-Fi equipment. That changes the role of the Hub in the household network.

    Check which existing Hub functions and connected devices you rely on before enabling modem mode, and keep the provider’s instructions for restoring your setup.

  • Overlooking a phone or other connected equipment

    Ofcom says digital landlines work through the broadband router, so a hub change may affect how the phone is connected.

    Speak to the provider before changing the setup if your household uses a digital landline, telecare equipment or an alarm connected through it.

Brand references

Which? includes TP-Link, Amazon Eero and Asus among the router brands in its UK testing; that does not establish how every model will perform in your home.

TP-Link

A brand to consider when comparing third-party routers; Which? includes TP-Link in its UK router testing.

  • Compare individual models against the rooms and devices you need to connect.
  • Check the exact model’s provider compatibility rather than assuming it applies across the range.

Amazon eero

Which? includes Amazon Eero among the router brands it tests for UK readers.

  • Consider the configuration of an individual model against your home’s coverage pattern.
  • Check its ports, provider connection method and any optional service terms before choosing it.

Asus

Which? includes Asus among the third-party router brands in its UK testing.

  • Compare the controls and connections offered by the specific model you are considering.
  • Do not assume every model has the same features or works with your provider’s setup.

Joybuy equipment for different routes

These options cover wider mesh coverage, one-area Wi-Fi extension, a wired adapter and a third-party router. Choose a route only after checking whether your existing broadband service or in-home connection needs attention.

NETGEAR Orbi 370 RBE373 three-pack mesh system

NETGEAR Orbi 370 RBE373 Wi-Fi 7 Mesh, 3-Pack

Consider a three-unit mesh setup when weak Wi-Fi affects several rooms, rather than one isolated spot.

The listed variant is dual-band BE3600 with 2.5Gbps Ethernet. Check how it will connect to your existing modem or gateway, and plan unit placement for your home.

Joybuy
TP-Link Deco BE22 three-pack mesh system

TP-Link Deco BE22 BE3600 Wi-Fi 7 Mesh, 3-Pack

This three-unit mesh option is relevant when coverage is weak across multiple parts of a home.

Plan where the units would sit and check how one will connect to your existing broadband equipment. Room layout and building materials matter when assessing the intended coverage.

Joybuy
TP-Link RE220BE Wi-Fi range extender

TP-Link RE220BE BE3600 Wi-Fi 7 Range Extender

Consider an extender when one area has weak Wi-Fi but the existing router otherwise meets your needs.

Place it where it can still receive the router’s signal. If you want EasyMesh features, check that your existing router is compatible.

Joybuy
HOCO HB42 USB Ethernet adapter and hub

HOCO HB42 USB Ethernet Adapter and Hub, 0.2 m

An adapter can give a compatible computer a wired connection for a fixed workspace or a comparison with its Wi-Fi connection.

This variant has an RJ45 LAN connection and three USB 3.0 ports. Check the computer’s USB port and whether you need to obtain a separate Ethernet cable.

Joybuy
TP-Link Archer NX500 5G AX3000 router

TP-Link Archer NX500 5G AX3000 Dual-Band Router

Consider this router only after deciding whether changing the main network equipment, rather than extending coverage, addresses the household’s problem.

Check your fixed-broadband provider’s access and setup requirements before connecting it to that service. If you plan to use its 5G/4G route, check the SIM service and coverage at your location; mesh expansion requires compatible additional equipment.

Joybuy

Common questions

Do I need faster broadband or better Wi-Fi?

Check provider status and compare Wi-Fi with a direct Ethernet connection where practical. If the problem affects the underlying service, new Wi-Fi equipment alone will not resolve it: Ofcom says Wi-Fi cannot outperform broadband.

When should I choose mesh instead of an extender?

Consider an extender for one targeted weak area when the rest of the home works adequately; consider mesh when coverage is weak across several rooms or floors. Which? describes mesh as a wider whole-home solution and an extender as the simpler targeted option.

Can I use my own router with a UK broadband provider?

You can consider one if it supports your particular service and provider settings. EE specifies PPPoE support, TalkTalk requires manual connection settings for a non-TalkTalk router, and Plusnet says an own-router model must be compatible with its network. Check your provider’s instructions before buying.

What should I check before using my own Wi-Fi kit with a Virgin Media Hub?

Check the instructions for your Hub model and the functions your household uses. Virgin Media describes modem mode as turning the Hub into a cable modem to connect your own Wi-Fi equipment, so plan how the rest of your setup will work before changing modes.

Could a router change affect my home phone?

Yes, if your digital landline connects through the broadband router. Ofcom advises households with dependent connected equipment to involve their provider when the landline setup changes; speak to yours before reconfiguring the hub if a phone, telecare device or alarm relies on it.