For an anniversary dessert for two, compare tubs around 440–500 ml, then choose a flavour and texture you both want: M&S lists a 500 ml olive-oil ice cream, Magnum describes a 440 ml chocolate-and-salted-caramel tub, and Tesco lists Ben & Jerry's Cookie Dough at 465 ml. If you need a vegan-labelled dessert, check the exact pack's allergy statement too; vegan labelling alone does not establish allergy suitability.
If you plan to share one tub rather than serve individual desserts, compare its quantity with what else you are serving. M&S describes its ice-cream pints as suitable for two to share, but that is not a fixed portion rule.
Agree on the eating experience before picking a flavour. Magnum describes a chocolate shell and shards in its Double Salted Caramel tub, while Ben & Jerry's Cookie Dough has pieces in a vanilla base.
Check the current pack against both diners' requirements. M&S labels its Plant Kitchen Soy Joy Cookie Dough ice cream vegan, but also says it is not suitable for people with several specified allergies or for coeliacs.
Start with the amount you want to serve, then settle on a texture both diners enjoy before checking the exact pack and your serving plans.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | Compare the stated net quantity, not just the word “sharing”. The M&S Collection example is 500 ml, Magnum Double Salted Caramel is 440 ml, and Tesco lists Ben & Jerry's Cookie Dough at 465 ml. | I want enough for two portions, taking any other dessert or toppings into account. |
| Flavour and texture | Check whether the tub has a smooth base, a chocolate shell, sauce or pieces. The named M&S olive-oil, Magnum salted-caramel and Ben & Jerry's cookie-dough tubs offer different combinations. | We should both want the flavour and texture, rather than choosing an unusual tub that only one of us will enjoy. |
| Dietary fit | Read the current ingredients, allergen statements and any “not suitable for” wording. M&S says its vegan-labelled Soy Joy Cookie Dough product is not suitable for coeliacs or for people with milk, nut, peanut or egg allergies. | If either of us has a dietary restriction or allergy, the statement on the exact pack matters more than the dessert style. |
| Storage | Follow the pack's frozen-storage and refreezing instructions. UK government food-storage guidance recommends a freezer around −18°C; the researched M&S tubs say not to refreeze. | I need to keep the tub frozen until it is time to serve dessert. |
| Collection plans | Check the chosen store or delivery location for the exact flavour before planning the final course around it. | I would rather settle on an available tub before deciding how to serve it. |
A plant-based label does not cover every allergy. M&S states that its vegan Soy Joy Cookie Dough product is not suitable for coeliacs or for people with milk, nut, peanut or egg allergies.
Compare the current pack's ingredients and suitability statements with both diners' requirements.
Magnum's chocolate shell and shards create a different dessert from Ben & Jerry's cookie-dough pieces or M&S's olive-oil ice cream.
Decide together whether you want a shell, chewy pieces or a tub without those additions, then choose a flavour.
The tub needs to remain frozen as its pack directs, and the flavour you plan to serve needs to be available at your chosen collection or delivery location.
Check the exact listing when arranging the shop, and follow the pack's storage instructions once the tub is home.
Serving sizes can differ between packs, making figures harder to compare directly.
If nutrition affects your choice, compare the current labels on the same stated basis, such as per 100 ml, as well as checking each pack's serving information.
M&S lists ice-cream tubs with distinctive flavours alongside plant-based options.
Magnum's Double Salted Caramel tub is a chocolate-and-caramel option with a shell and shards.
Cookie Dough is an option when both diners want pieces in a vanilla ice cream rather than a smooth scoop.
Tesco's frozen-dessert category groups tubs alongside luxury, vegan and gluten-free listings.
These Joybuy options include 460–465 ml ice-cream tubs for a shared dessert and two larger 1 L kulfi tubs. Choose between them according to the flavour you both want, the quantity you plan to serve and the pack's dietary information.
Image unavailable
Consider the 460 ml tub if you both want a praline-and-cream flavour. Check the current pack if egg, milk or pecan matters to either diner, and confirm availability for your location.
Image unavailable
The 465 ml tub suits two diners who agree on a churro-inspired flavour with pieces and swirls. Check the current pack for milk, wheat, egg and precautionary nut information, and confirm local availability.
Image unavailable
Choose this 465 ml tub if both diners want chocolate-chip cookie dough in vanilla ice cream, as Joybuy describes it. Check the current pack for milk, wheat, egg and soya information, along with its storage instructions.
Image unavailable
This pistachio kulfi is a 1 L tub, so decide whether you want that quantity for a dinner for two. Check the current pack for milk and pistachio information and follow its storage instructions.
Image unavailable
Consider the cardamom-and-saffron flavour if both diners want that style of dessert and a 1 L tub suits your plans. Check the current pack for milk information and follow its serving and storage directions.
It is a useful range to compare, not a fixed serving rule. M&S describes its ice-cream pints as suitable for two to share; check the quantity on your chosen tub and consider whether you will serve anything alongside it.
No. M&S labels its Plant Kitchen Soy Joy Cookie Dough product vegan but says it is not suitable for people with a milk allergy. Check the current pack's full ingredient and allergy statements against the diner's requirements.
Check the current ingredients and precautionary allergen statement. Magnum's product information describes dairy ice cream and lists a may-contain warning for wheat, barley, oat and nuts.
Keep it frozen according to its pack instructions. UK government guidance recommends a freezer around −18°C, and the researched M&S products say not to refreeze them after thawing.