Hosts offering an extra sweet
If guests can choose a chocolate-orange cake as well as a scone, plan the pack around those likely to take one. The total guest count alone may lead you to buy more cakes than you intend to serve.
Who is this for?
A sharing pack makes most sense when Jaffa Cakes are an additional choice on the cream-tea table, rather than a replacement for scones, jam and cream.
Shoppers serving a larger table
Retailer listings give stated counts of 24, 30, 36 and 40 cakes. Compare those counts with the portions you plan to offer, then confirm that your chosen format is in stock.
Hosts checking food allergies
Declarations differ between the listed products. Check the physical pack you will serve, rather than assuming that another brand or pack size has the same ingredients and allergen warnings.
What should you check?
Decide how many cakes you expect to serve, then check the particular pack’s stock and label before settling on a format.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Cake count | Check the number of cakes, not weight alone. Sainsbury’s lists a 24-cake pack; ASDA lists 30- and 36-cake formats; Waitrose lists a 40-cake format. | I’m offering one cake to each guest who wants an extra sweet, so I need enough individual cakes without assuming everyone will take one. |
| Place on the table | Decide whether Jaffa Cakes sit beside the scones or are one of several additional sweets. Check whether a full-size or mini format fits the portions you intend to offer. | A small chocolate-orange option alongside the scones would suit my table better than making Jaffa Cakes the sole sweet. |
| Allergen declaration | Read the exact pack before serving. ASDA’s McVitie’s 30-cake listing declares soya, egg, milk and wheat; M&S says its 250g dark-chocolate pack is unsuitable for people with nut or peanut allergies. | If a guest has an allergy, I need the declaration for the product I will actually put on the table. |
| Stock | Check the current listing or local store. The ASDA 36-cake Party Pack and Waitrose 40-cake Pole listings showed those formats as unavailable. | I need a pack I can obtain for the gathering, even if that means choosing a different cake count. |
| Leftovers | Compare the pack size with likely demand and read its instructions for storage after opening. | With other sweets already planned, I would rather choose a quantity I expect to use. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Searching only for a sharing bag
The larger listed formats include a party pack and a pole containing cartons, not just pouch-style packaging. A search based on pack shape can miss a useful cake count.
Compare the stated number of cakes across formats before deciding which package to buy.
-
Planning around the largest pack without checking stock
ASDA’s 36-cake Party Pack and Waitrose’s 40-cake Pole were marked unavailable on their listings. Their counts remain useful for planning, but do not establish that either can be bought for your gathering.
Confirm current stock and keep another suitable pack size in mind.
-
Assuming every pack has the same allergen warning
Product declarations differ. Sainsbury’s warns that its 24-cake pack is unsuitable for customers with a milk allergy, while M&S gives a nut and peanut allergy warning for its 250g dark-chocolate pack.
Read the current physical pack before serving it to guests, and keep the packaging available for them to check.
-
Treating Jaffa Cakes as the whole cream tea
A large cake count does not replace the scones, jam and cream at the centre of the occasion. It can leave you with more Jaffa Cakes than planned if they are only an extra choice.
Set the quantity for that additional role, taking the other food on the table into account.
Brand and retailer references
These product lines offer different counts and formats; the details and allergen warnings apply to the named packs, not every product from a brand.
McVitie’s
ASDA and Waitrose list McVitie’s orange Jaffa Cake formats containing 30, 36 or 40 cakes.
- The stated counts make it possible to plan portions for a larger table.
- The listed 36- and 40-cake formats were marked unavailable; check stock before choosing either.
Sainsbury’s
Its own-label 282g Jaffa Cakes pack contains 24 cakes, a count to consider when they are an extra sweet.
- The individual cake count helps with portion planning.
- The listing showed the pack out of stock and states that it is unsuitable for customers with a milk allergy.
M&S
M&S lists a 250g dark-chocolate Jaffa Cakes pack and 100g mini formats.
- The 250g pack is described by M&S as suitable for sharing.
- M&S states that the 250g pack is unsuitable for people with nut or peanut allergies; check local stock and the pack label.
Waitrose
Waitrose lists a 125g Mini Jaffa Cakes pack with five stated servings, as well as larger McVitie’s formats.
- The mini pack has a stated serving count for a smaller tea.
- Its declaration says it may contain milk; check the current pack where that matters.
Asda
ASDA lists a 150g own-label Jaffa Cakes pack with 12 suggested servings alongside larger McVitie’s packs.
- The suggested serving count helps distinguish the smaller pack from the 30- and 36-cake listings.
- The own-label pack declares wheat, soya and egg; check its full current allergen statement.
Tesco
Tesco’s category listing includes McVitie’s triple and twin packs and a Tesco Orange Jaffa Cake twin pack.
- The listed pack types give shoppers several formats to compare.
- Use the individual product detail and physical pack to confirm count, ingredients and allergens for the format you choose.
Joybuy product options
This McVitie’s triple pack is an option when Jaffa Cakes are an additional sweet for a cream-tea gathering. Check its cake count against the portions you plan to serve.
No image available
McVitie’s Jaffa Cakes Original Triple Pack 330g
For a cream tea where Jaffa Cakes are an extra sweet, compare the cake count on this triple pack with the number of guests you expect to serve. Read its current allergen declaration before putting it on the table.
Questions about serving Jaffa Cakes
Do Jaffa Cakes replace scones at a cream tea?
No. Serve them as an optional chocolate-orange accompaniment to the scones, jam and cream, then choose a pack according to how many guests are likely to want that extra sweet.
How many Jaffa Cakes should I buy?
Start with the number of guests you expect to take one, rather than using pack weight as a portion count. Sainsbury’s lists a 24-cake pack, while ASDA and Waitrose list McVitie’s formats of 30, 36 and 40 cakes; check stock for the size you choose.
Can I assume Jaffa Cakes are suitable for a guest with an allergy?
No. ASDA’s McVitie’s 30-cake listing declares soya, egg, milk and wheat; Sainsbury’s 24-cake listing warns against use for a milk allergy; and M&S says its 250g dark-chocolate pack is unsuitable for people with nut or peanut allergies. Read the declaration on the physical pack you will serve.
What should I do with Jaffa Cakes left after the tea?
Follow the storage instructions on the pack you bought, including its directions for after opening. Keep the packaging so those instructions remain available when you put the remaining cakes away.