Parents choosing an occasional holiday snack
A ready-to-drink carton can be convenient at home, but its sugars and serving size matter alongside the fat figure.
Who is choosing these drinks?
The useful comparison changes with the size of the snack, how it will be served and whether milk is suitable for the child.
Families comparing sugars in flavoured drinks
The nutrition panel helps distinguish a no-added-sugar claim from the amount of sugars actually listed for a serving.
Households buying bottles to share
A 1-litre bottle can provide several servings. Compare drinks per 100ml, then decide how much to pour for one snack.
What should you compare?
Start with the nutrition panel on a common per-100ml basis, then check the serving, milk declaration and storage instructions against your plans.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Fat and sugars | Read both figures per 100ml before comparing packs. Tesco Groceries lists Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate at 1.4g fat and 4.7g sugars; Sainsbury’s lists its Chocolate Milkshake at 1.2g fat and 8.9g sugars. | I want to compare sugars as well as fat, rather than choosing whichever carton has the smaller fat figure. |
| Serving size | Check the bottle or carton volume and the nutrition per serving. Tesco Groceries lists Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate in 200ml cartons and FRijj Chocolate Fudge Brownie in a 471ml bottle; Sainsbury’s Chocolate Milkshake comes in a 1-litre bottle. | For one snack, I may prefer a measured serving to treating a large bottle as one portion. |
| Milk ingredients | Read the current pack’s allergen declaration. Tesco Groceries identifies milk in the Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate and FRijj Chocolate Fudge Brownie products. | If a child has a milk allergy, I need to check the ingredients before serving the drink. |
| Storage | Follow the particular pack’s chilling and after-opening instructions. Tesco Groceries says to refrigerate opened Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate and use it within three days; its FRijj listing says to keep the drink refrigerated and use it within three days of opening. | On an outing, I need a pack whose storage instructions I can follow throughout the day. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Choosing by fat alone
The smaller fat figure need not come with fewer sugars. Per 100ml, Sainsbury’s Chocolate Milkshake lists 1.2g fat and 8.9g sugars, while Tesco Groceries lists Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate at 1.4g fat and 4.7g sugars.
Compare both lines per 100ml, then check the amount you intend to serve.
-
Reading “no added sugar” as “sugar-free”
Tesco Groceries lists 4.7g sugars per 100ml, or 9.4g per 200ml carton, for Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate.
Check the “of which sugars” line even when the front of the pack says “no added sugar”.
-
Overlooking bottle size
The 471ml FRijj Chocolate Fudge Brownie bottle listed by Tesco Groceries holds more than twice the volume of a 200ml carton. Its per-100ml figures do not describe the amount in the whole bottle.
Decide on a serving before pouring from a larger bottle.
-
Confusing lactose-reduced with milk-free
A lactose-reduced description does not remove a milk allergen: Tesco Groceries identifies milk in Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate.
For someone with a milk allergy, follow the current pack’s allergen declaration rather than the lactose wording.
Brand and product references
These figures describe the named products and pack formats, not every drink made by each brand.
Yazoo
The Chocolate drinks listed by Tesco Groceries include a No Added Sugar 200ml carton and a standard 1-litre bottle.
- The No Added Sugar Chocolate carton lists 1.4g fat and 4.7g sugars per 100ml; a 200ml carton lists 2.8g fat and 9.4g sugars.
- Tesco Groceries lists 8.6g sugars per 100ml for the standard Chocolate 1-litre bottle, compared with 4.7g for the No Added Sugar carton. Check which variant you have; the carton contains milk.
Sainsbury’s
Sainsbury’s Chocolate Milkshake is a 1-litre drink described in its listing as made with British 1% fat milk.
- Sainsbury’s lists 1.2g fat per 100ml for this product, compared with Tesco Groceries’ 1.4g for Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate.
- It lists 8.9g sugars per 100ml, so the lower fat figure does not make it the lower-sugar choice in that comparison.
FRijj
The Chocolate Fudge Brownie variant listed by Tesco Groceries comes in a 471ml bottle.
- Its 471ml format can be portioned out when more than one serving is wanted.
- Tesco Groceries lists 1.8g fat and 10.8g sugars per 100ml for this milk-containing variant; check the amount poured rather than using the bottle as the serving measure.
Mars
A BritishGram listing describes a 350ml Mars Chocolate Milk Shake Drink made with milk and carrying a no-added-sugar claim.
- The 350ml pack size is stated in the listing, making portion size straightforward to check.
- The listed 2.2% fat describes a milk ingredient, not the drink’s fat per 100ml. Compare the current pack’s full nutrition panel before choosing it for its fat or sugars.
Joybuy product options
These are ready-to-drink LIGHT UP yoghurt milkshake options in 220ml bottles, rather than the chocolate flavoured-milk products compared above. Check their current labels before choosing one as a child’s snack.
No image available
LIGHT UP Zero Control Avocado Kale Chia Seed Milkshake Yoghurt Drink, 220ml × 3
The three-bottle pack offers individual 220ml drinks for separate snacks. The listing’s no-added-sugar claim conflicts with sugar listed in the fruit preparation, so check the current pack’s ingredients and nutrition panel rather than relying on that claim. It contains milk; check the label for any age-related guidance and follow its storage and after-opening instructions.
No image available
LIGHT UP Zero Control Avocado Kale Chia Seed Milkshake Yoghurt Drink, 220ml
This 220ml bottle is a single-drink format. The listing’s no-added-sugar claim conflicts with sugar listed in the fruit preparation, so check the current pack’s ingredients and nutrition panel before comparing it with other drinks. It contains milk; check the label for any age-related guidance and follow its storage and after-opening instructions.
Questions about milkshake snacks
Does less fat mean fewer sugars in a milkshake?
No. Sainsbury’s lists 1.2g fat and 8.9g sugars per 100ml for its Chocolate Milkshake, while Tesco Groceries lists 1.4g fat and 4.7g sugars per 100ml for Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate. Compare both figures on the same per-100ml basis and check the serving size.
Is a no-added-sugar milkshake sugar-free?
Not necessarily. Tesco Groceries lists 4.7g sugars per 100ml and 9.4g per 200ml carton for Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate. Read the current nutrition panel rather than treating the front-of-pack wording as a sugars figure.
How does a milkshake fit alongside a child’s usual drinks?
For young children, NHS guidance identifies water and pasteurised milk as the usual drink choices and links sugary drinks with tooth-decay risk. A flavoured milkshake is better considered as an occasional snack than as a replacement for water throughout the day.
What should I check before serving a milkshake to a child with a milk allergy?
Check the current pack’s allergen declaration and do not assume that “lactose reduced” means milk-free. Tesco Groceries identifies milk in Yazoo No Added Sugar Chocolate and FRijj Chocolate Fudge Brownie.
Can a milkshake go into a school bag after the holidays?
Check the individual school’s policy on packed drinks and the product’s storage instructions. GOV.UK’s school-food guidance concerns food and drink provided in state-funded schools in England; its scope does not establish permission for a particular drink brought from home.