Who is this choice for?

Buyers requiring a reduced-sugar claim

If reduced sugar is a firm requirement, check the claim and its comparison basis on the product you intend to buy. Do not substitute an ordinary or Free From custard cream solely because its sugar figure looks lower.

Households comparing sugar figures

If an explicit reduced-sugar claim is not essential, compare sugars per 100g across custard creams. Then consider sugars per biscuit, pack size and whether portion packs suit the household.

Buyers with dietary exclusions

Check the ingredients and allergen statement before comparing sugar figures. A gluten-free, milk-free or vegan description addresses a different question from whether a biscuit is reduced in sugar.

What should you check before buying?

Settle whether you require a reduced-sugar claim or simply want to compare published sugar figures, then check the packs against the same criteria.

PriorityWhat to checkYour needs
Reduced-sugar claim Look for an explicit claim and a clear comparison with a similar product. Check sugars per 100g separately; a lower figure does not itself establish a reduced-sugar claim. I need the biscuit itself to meet a reduced-sugar requirement, rather than choosing by its packaging or dietary label.
Sugar comparison Compare sugars per 100g across packs of different sizes. Also read sugars per biscuit or portion and any traffic-light indicator shown. Before ordering several packs, I want to compare the nutrition declarations on the same basis and understand what each portion contains.
Dietary suitability Read the ingredients, declared allergens and any relevant Free From or vegan wording on the pack. Recheck these details when ordering again. Someone in my household avoids particular ingredients, so the allergen information matters independently of the sugar figure.
Bulk-use format Check total pack weight, the number of inner packs and the best-before date. Follow the storage directions on each pack. Portion packs may suit how we use the biscuits, while a larger shared pack may suit a different routine.

Common buying mistakes

  • Treating a lower sugar figure as a reduced-sugar claim

    One custard cream can list fewer grams of sugar per 100g than another without making a reduced-sugar claim. That distinction matters when the claim is a condition of your bulk purchase.

    Check for an explicit claim and its comparison basis. Otherwise, describe your choice as lower in published sugars than the products you compared.

  • Assuming Free From means reduced sugar

    Free From wording can identify a relevant dietary exclusion, but it does not establish a sugar reduction.

    Check dietary suitability and sugars per 100g as separate parts of the decision.

  • Choosing a large pack without reading its nutrition panel

    ASDA Groceries lists 29g sugars per 100g and 3.4g per biscuit for its standard 400g custard creams, with the per-biscuit sugars marked high. Pack weight does not answer the sugar question.

    Decide whether you require a reduced-sugar claim, then compare the nutrition figures and pack formats before buying several packs.

  • Using an old label for a repeat order

    The information you relied on for an earlier purchase may not match the pack you receive later, particularly if ingredients or nutrition declarations change.

    Read each pack’s current ingredients, allergen statement and nutrition panel, especially where a dietary exclusion is essential.

Brand references for comparison

ASDA

Its standard 400g custard creams provide a larger-pack reference for comparing published sugar figures.

  • ASDA Groceries lists 29g sugars per 100g and 3.4g per biscuit for the standard pack.
  • The listing marks sugars high per biscuit; its standard custard creams contain wheat and milk.

Sainsbury's

Its standard 200g custard creams offer a smaller-pack reference for a like-for-like sugar comparison.

  • Sainsbury's lists 26.5g sugars per 100g and 3.3g per biscuit.
  • The listing marks sugars high per biscuit; the product contains wheat and milk.

Schär

Its Gluten-Free Custard Creams are relevant when comparing a portion-packed dietary option with standard custard creams.

  • The ASDA Groceries listing gives 23g sugars per 100g for the 125g product and describes it as wheat-free and suitable for vegans.
  • A 23g-per-100g declaration does not, on its own, establish a reduced-sugar claim.

M&S

Its Extra Cream Custard Creams provide a reference for a different custard-cream format.

  • M&S describes the product as containing extra vanilla cream and real custard powder.
  • The M&S nutrition declaration lists 40.2g sugars per 100g.

McVitie's

Its Family Circle assortment includes a custard cream among several biscuit varieties.

  • The Tesco Groceries listing identifies a custard cream within the 400g assortment.
  • The listed 26.2g sugars per 100g applies to the assortment, not to a standalone McVitie's custard cream.

Joybuy custard cream options

This portion-packed custard cream is an option for comparing published sugar figures and checking gluten-free and vegan suitability. A lower figure is not the same as an explicit reduced-sugar claim.

Schär Gluten-Free Custard Creams 125g

Schär Gluten-Free Custard Creams 125g

For comparing sugar declarations where a formal reduced-sugar claim is not required: the ASDA Groceries listing for this product states 23g sugars per 100g. It is a 125g gluten-free custard cream product listed as suitable for vegans; check the pack’s current ingredients and allergen information for your requirements.

View on Joybuy

Questions about bulk buying

Does gluten-free, vegan or Free From mean reduced sugar?

No. Those descriptions address dietary characteristics, not whether a custard cream makes a reduced-sugar claim. Compare sugars per 100g, and check for an explicit claim if reduced sugar is a firm requirement.

What should I compare before buying several packs?

Start with sugars per 100g to compare different pack sizes on the same basis. Then check sugars per biscuit or portion, allergens, pack format and storage instructions. ASDA Groceries and Sainsbury's both mark sugars high per biscuit on their standard custard cream listings.

Can a lower-sugar figure satisfy a strict reduced-sugar requirement?

Not by itself. A lower published figure shows how the products you checked compare per 100g; if you require a reduced-sugar claim, check that the product explicitly makes one and identifies a suitable comparison basis.

How should I store a bulk purchase?

Follow the storage instructions and best-before date on each pack. Check the directions for opened packs rather than assuming every custard cream or repeat order has the same storage guidance.

Should I recheck ingredients when ordering the same biscuits again?

Yes. Read the current ingredients and allergen statement on every repeat purchase, particularly if someone needs to avoid wheat, milk or possible cross-contact.