Who is choosing?

Start with the requirement the biscuit must meet: sugar-free, a stated allergen exclusion, or a familiar Bourbon format.

Organisers seeking a sugar-free biscuit

A cocoa sandwich biscuit may work if an exact Bourbon cream is not required. Diablo Sugar Free labels its cocoa-and-vanilla biscuit sugar free, but it contains wheat, milk and soya and carries an excessive-consumption warning on the Holland & Barrett listing.

Organisers seeking gluten-free and milk-free Bourbons

Tesco, Sainsbury's and Asda list free-from Bourbon biscuits for this different requirement. Their ingredient lists include sugar, so do not use them to meet a sugar-free request.

Volunteers planning allergen-aware serving

Keep each product’s packaging and allergen information available. Anaphylaxis UK recommends a separate area and separate utensils for allergy-friendly bakes; confirm the school’s own arrangements before setting up the stall.

What should you check?

Decide whether the sugar claim or the Bourbon format is essential, then check the allergens and how the biscuits will be served.

Priority What to check Your needs
Sugar claim Look for an explicit sugar-free claim if that is required. Check the ingredients and nutrition panel; a free-from or no-added-sugar claim answers a different question. I need a biscuit specifically labelled sugar free, rather than a Bourbon cream that happens to be gluten-free or milk-free.
Allergens Read the current pack’s allergen declaration. Diablo Sugar Free lists wheat, milk and soya; check any free-from claim for the particular allergens it covers. Some pupils need to avoid particular ingredients, so I want each biscuit’s own packaging available to check before serving.
Sweetener Check which sweetener is used and retain any on-pack consumption warning. Diablo Sugar Free uses maltitol, and the Holland & Barrett listing warns about excessive consumption. A sugar-free label alone does not tell me everything I need to know about the biscuit’s ingredients or nutrition.
Serving Confirm the school’s allergy policy. Follow Anaphylaxis UK’s bake-sale advice to provide allergen information and use separate areas and utensils for allergy-friendly items. I want volunteers to be able to identify each biscuit and avoid mixing allergy-friendly products with other bakes.

What can go wrong?

  • Reading “free from” as “sugar free”

    The Tesco, Sainsbury's and Asda free-from Bourbon products exclude stated allergens, but their published ingredients include sugar. They do not meet a strict sugar-free request.

    Check the sugar claim separately from the allergen claims, using the pack supplied for the sale.

  • Assuming sugar-free means allergen-free

    Diablo Sugar Free’s cocoa sandwich biscuit contains wheat, milk and soya. Its retailer listing also carries an excessive-consumption warning.

    Keep its original packaging at the stall and do not place it among products labelled free from those allergens.

  • Mixing products while serving

    Separate packaging cannot prevent confusion if biscuits are moved between displays or served with shared utensils.

    Follow Anaphylaxis UK’s advice to set aside an area and utensils for allergy-friendly bakes, with allergen information visible to volunteers and customers.

  • Using an online listing in place of the pack

    The biscuit brought to school needs to be identified by its own ingredients, allergen declaration and warnings.

    Check the physical pack before the sale and leave it available when the biscuits are served.

Relevant product lines

These product lines address different requirements; a gluten-free Bourbon is not necessarily a sugar-free one.

Diablo Sugar Free

Its 176g Extra Dark Cocoa Flavour Sandwich Cookie with Vanilla Cream is labelled sugar free and sweetened with maltitol. It is a cocoa sandwich biscuit, not a traditional Bourbon cream.

  • Diablo’s product information identifies the sugar-free claim and lists wheat, milk and soya as allergens.
  • Holland & Barrett’s listing warns that excessive consumption may produce laxative effects.

Tesco Free From

Tesco Free From Bourbon Creams are listed as gluten-free and milk-free cocoa biscuits with a cocoa filling.

  • The listed format is a Bourbon cream for shoppers seeking those stated allergen exclusions.
  • The ingredients include sugar, so this product does not meet a sugar-free requirement.

Sainsbury's Free From

Sainsbury's Free From Bourbon Creams are listed as gluten-free, milk-free and suitable for vegans.

  • They offer a Bourbon-cream format where the stated free-from requirements matter.
  • Their ingredients include sugar; they are not a sugar-free substitute.

Asda Free From

Asda Free From Bourbon Biscuits are listed as free from milk and cereals containing gluten, and suitable for vegans.

  • They retain a Bourbon-style format for shoppers seeking the stated free-from claims.
  • The ingredients include sugar and glucose syrup, so they do not meet a sugar-free brief.

McVitie's Tasties

McVitie's Tasties Bourbon Cream Biscuits are a conventional Bourbon-cream option when neither sugar-free nor gluten-free status is required.

  • The product has the familiar Bourbon-cream format.
  • The Asda listing identifies wheat and sugar in the product, and says it may contain milk and sesame.

Joybuy product options

These are biscuit alternatives to consider when the sugar claim matters more than an exact Bourbon cream. “Zero Sugar” and “No Added Sugar” are different claims; check the current pack, allergens and product-page availability before planning the sale around either item.

Oreo Zero Sugar Sandwich Cookies, 97g

Oreo Zero Sugar Sandwich Cookies, 97g

The Zero Sugar claim makes this a biscuit to check for a sugar-free bake-sale request, although it is not a traditional Bourbon. The supplied product information identifies wheat and soya; keep the physical pack available to check all ingredients and warnings.

Joybuy’s product listing says this item is no longer available. Check the linked page before relying on it for the sale.

View on Joybuy
Gullon Zero No Added Sugar Cookies and Cream 210g

Gullon Zero No Added Sugar Cookies and Cream 210g

This cookies-and-cream option is labelled No Added Sugar, which is not the same claim as sugar free. The supplied product information identifies wheat and soya, notes possible milk and mustard, and carries an excessive-consumption warning associated with maltitol. Check the current pack against the school’s requirements.

View on Joybuy

Questions about the bake sale

Are free-from Bourbon creams sugar free?

Not the Tesco, Sainsbury's or Asda products described here. Their published ingredient lists include sugar, even though the products carry gluten-free and milk-free claims. Check the physical pack for whichever requirement the sale needs to meet.

Is Diablo’s sugar-free biscuit a Bourbon cream?

No. Diablo describes its 176g product as an extra dark cocoa flavour sandwich cookie with vanilla cream. It is a sugar-free cocoa sandwich option when that format is acceptable instead of a traditional Bourbon.

Which allergens does Diablo’s sugar-free biscuit contain?

Diablo’s product information lists wheat (gluten), milk and soya. Do not present it as free from any of those allergens, and keep its current packaging available for checking.

How should we handle allergen information at a school bake sale?

Confirm the school’s allergy arrangements before the sale and keep product information with the biscuits. Department for Education guidance addresses schools’ support for pupils with allergies; Anaphylaxis UK recommends providing allergen information and separating allergy-friendly bakes and their serving utensils.