Hosts preparing several dishes
If the menu includes chilli, beans and tomato-based sauces, count how many tins each recipe calls for before choosing a pack. Separate 400g tins can be opened as each dish is made.
Who is buying for BBQ prep?
Cooks choosing a particular sauce texture
Chopped tomatoes leave visible pieces, finely chopped tomatoes offer a finer cut, and whole plum tomatoes can be crushed or blended. The right format depends on the finish you want and the preparation you are willing to do.
Households planning around leftovers
Consider how much one cooking session will use before opening a large tin. Opened-product instructions vary: Marks & Spencer directs buyers of its 400g chopped tomatoes to transfer leftovers to a non-metallic container, refrigerate them and eat them within three days.
What should you check?
Start with the dishes and texture you want, then match the tin size and opened-storage instructions to your cooking plan.
| Priority | What to check | Your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity and portions | Check the number of tins and net weight per tin. Decide whether separate 400g tins or a larger single tin matches the amounts your recipes require. | I am making several dishes at different times and want to open only the tins each recipe needs. |
| Tomato cut | Check whether the tomatoes are chopped, finely chopped or whole plum. Whole tomatoes require crushing or blending if the recipe calls for a broken-down base. | For a sauce with visible tomato pieces, chopped works for me; for a finer finish, I would choose a finer cut or plan to blend. |
| Opened storage | Read the specific tin’s instructions for transferring, refrigerating and using opened contents. Do not apply one product’s stated period to another. | If a recipe uses only part of a tin, I need a plan for the remainder. Marks & Spencer, for example, says to refrigerate its opened 400g chopped tomatoes in a non-metallic container and eat them within three days. |
| Date marking | Check the date and unopened-storage directions on the can. GOV.UK distinguishes best-before dates, which concern quality, from use-by dates, which concern safety, and lists canned tomatoes among foods commonly marked best before. | I am stocking up before a BBQ and want to keep unopened tins as directed, rather than treating a best-before date as a use-by deadline. |
What can go wrong?
-
Choosing the cut without considering the sauce
Chopped tomatoes retain pieces that may need blending for a smooth glaze. Whole plum tomatoes need crushing or blending when the recipe calls for a broken-down base.
Decide on the intended texture before choosing chopped, finely chopped or whole plum tomatoes, and allow for any blending the recipe needs.
-
Opening a large tin without a leftovers plan
Once a tin is open, its storage instructions matter. For its 400g chopped tomatoes, Marks & Spencer specifies a non-metallic container, refrigeration and use within three days; another product may give different directions.
Choose separately opened tins if the dishes will be cooked on different days, and follow the instructions on the tin you open.
A larger tin can also leave you with more opened tomato to store and use within its stated period.
-
Confusing best before with use by
GOV.UK says best-before dates concern quality, while use-by dates concern safety. Canned tomatoes are among the foods it identifies as commonly carrying a best-before date.
Read the can’s date marking and storage directions, and take the condition of the can into account rather than treating the date alone as the whole decision.
Relevant brand references
These examples describe particular tomato formats and listings, not every product made by each brand.
Tesco
Tesco Groceries lists its Italian Chopped Tomatoes in a 4 x 400g pack, providing a standard chopped format to consider for multi-dish preparation.
- Four separate 400g tins can be allocated across planned recipes.
- Check the individual listing and tin for ingredients and storage directions relevant to your cooking plan.
Napolina
Napolina lists a 4 x 400g chopped-tomato pack, and Tesco Groceries also lists a 4 x 400g Napolina plum-tomato pack.
- Napolina describes its chopped tomatoes as chunky and packed in tomato juice, a distinction worth considering for a textured sauce.
- Choose the chopped or plum format according to whether you want pieces ready to use or whole tomatoes to break down yourself.
Mutti
Tesco Groceries lists Mutti Finely Chopped Tomatoes in a 4 x 400g pack; Mutti distinguishes chopped tomatoes from passata in its range.
- The finely chopped format is an option when smaller tomato pieces suit the planned sauce.
- Finely chopped tomatoes and passata are distinct formats; check the recipe before substituting one for the other.
M&S
Marks & Spencer lists Italian plum tomatoes in 400g and 1.6kg formats, alongside a separate 400g chopped-tomato product.
- The listed plum-tomato sizes offer a choice between a standard tin and a larger quantity for a planned batch.
- Its 400g chopped tomatoes require transfer to a non-metallic container, refrigeration and use within three days after opening. Check the instructions on the particular product you buy.
Tinned tomato options on Joybuy
These chopped, finely chopped and plum-tomato multipacks offer different cuts and numbers of separately opened tins for BBQ sauces and sides. Choose by recipe texture and how much you plan to open at once.
No image available
Laila Canned Chopped Tomatoes 12 x 400g
Twelve separate 400g tins suit a plan involving several chopped-tomato sauces or sides. After opening a tin, transfer the contents to a non-metallic airtight container, refrigerate and use within two days, as directed in the product information.
No image available
Mutti Finely Chopped Tomatoes 4 x 400g
The finely chopped cut suits a sauce where you want smaller tomato pieces; four 400g tins can be opened separately. The product information directs refrigeration after opening and use within five days. Follow the instructions on the pack.
No image available
Napolina Chopped Tomatoes 6 x 400g
Six separate 400g tins provide chopped tomatoes for multiple planned dishes. The product information says to transfer opened contents to a non-metallic container, refrigerate and use within two days.
No image available
Laila Canned Plum Tomatoes 12 x 400g
Whole plum tomatoes can be crushed or blended to suit the planned sauce, which adds a preparation step. This pack contains twelve separate 400g tins. The product information directs you to refrigerate opened contents in a non-metallic airtight container and use them within two days.
No image available
Napolina Peeled Plum Tomatoes 4 x 400g
Four separate 400g tins of peeled plum tomatoes suit recipes where you want to crush or blend whole tomatoes yourself. Allow for that step when preparing a sauce. The product information directs refrigeration and use within two days after opening.
Frequently asked questions
Which tomato cut should I use for a BBQ sauce?
Choose chopped tomatoes if visible pieces suit the sauce, finely chopped tomatoes if you want smaller pieces, or whole plum tomatoes if you plan to crush or blend them yourself. A smoother finish may still call for blending or further cooking, depending on the recipe.
Should I choose separate tins or one large tin?
Separate tins suit dishes made at different times because you can open only what each recipe needs. Consider a larger tin when one cooking session will use most of it; Marks & Spencer lists Italian plum tomatoes in both 400g and 1.6kg formats.
How should I store tomatoes after opening a tin?
Follow the instructions on that product rather than assuming one period applies to every tin. For its 400g chopped tomatoes, Marks & Spencer says to transfer leftovers to a non-metallic container, refrigerate and eat them within three days.
What does a best-before date mean on tinned tomatoes?
A best-before date concerns quality, not the same safety deadline as a use-by date, according to GOV.UK, which lists canned tomatoes among foods commonly marked best before. Check the can’s condition and storage instructions when deciding what to use.